Gay Anal Plug Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Category
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com
Create your own smut fantasy with AI

Return from Spring Break

by WFEATHER on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The anal plug was buried deep within me, and as I tapped on the base of the thick, hearty plug, I once again felt a thrill as I felt he vibrations of that tapping cascading into me. With each tap, my breath caught briefly in my throat, and my manhood throbbed against the pillow beneath me. Yet part of the exhilaration of the moment was the noise coming from...

Trained to Crave Cocks

by Red10Dog on Oct 22, 2019
Gay Male

It was getting late one night when I received a text from my Master "Bitch put your anal plug in your ass and get over here NOW!" I jump up out of my chair and ran to the bedroom and pushed my jeweled anal plug in my ass pulled my shorts up and drove to his home. It is a beautiful full moon warm night. I drive to Master's home and get out of my truck. I op...

A Secret Life Ch. 04

by ingarlm on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Note: I posted quite a short last chapter because I felt this bit needed to be on its own. I'm not quite sure why the story took this turn but I think it works so I've left it as first written. This chapter features fairly mild and consensual D/s with spanking and anal plugs. If that isn't your thing then you can skip to chapter 5 (the last one) which shoul...

Blue Rabbit Surprise

by alexcarr on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

"I thought I'd buy you a special present Pete, maybe you'd like to open it right now?" "I guess this is a going away present, Jeff?" Jeff was going to do a report abroad and would be some days before he was back, so it came as no real surprise because he always got me something every time he went away. I opened it and saw that it had on the box "Blue Rabb...

28-year-old Bisexual Stepfather Ch. 05

by walterio on Feb 6, 2018
Gay Male

AUTHOR'S NOTE: This story contains straight sex, bisexual sex, gay sex and incest. DUSTIN GIVES IN TO HIS ANAL DESIRE It had been weeks since Dustin had anal sex and Brandon would not be home for another four weeks. He had not been with the sisters and he was still haunted by the scene with Rick and Tyler. The consulting gig had wrapped up and he was now a...

Paul's First Assfucking Pt. 01

by JohnLeslie on Sep 17, 2017
Gay Male

My name is Paul, I am 40, tall, athletic, handsome and masculine. My girlfriend Michelle, is a cute 21 year old college senior with long black hair, a slightly curvy body and big boobs with sand dollar like nipples. We have an amazing sex life and often fantasize about threesomes and foursomes. Usually, I am very dominant sexually with her and the other wome...

Becoming a Cum Dump Ch. 06

by plyasian on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The problem with going to bed early was that I woke up early. On a Sunday too. Uh. I opened my eyes giving up trying to get back to sleep. 7:35am. Fuck. I immediately went to my computer and waited. The last email that I read opened up. Don't jack off. You'll receive an email tomorrow at 8:00am. More instructions to follow. MT I was horny and wanted to...

Hardcore Holiday Ch. 02

by the_apocalypse on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Mikey stood there with his finger working my male g-spot for at least twenty minutes until, without saying a word, he slowly pulled it out and walked back into my room and got his shorts back on. "Will you be around later?" he asked as he headed to the door. I turned to face him, my cock as hard as rock and pointing directly towards him. "Surely you can't...

Blink: Five

by KenjiDeSade on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The following story is a fictional account. The characters are entirely unreal and so are their situations. Thus no direct attention was paid to probability or safety for the characters. Such practices should not transfer over to real life situations. Practice safe, sane and consensual sex. For your own damn good. If you have problems or issues with queer po...

My Journey Ch. 02

by lonesomejones on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

We cuddled in silence for a while. I felt fully relaxed, if not still a bit tipsy, enjoying the afterglow of my first penetration and the feeling of fullness in my bottom. There was a very slight breeze and the moon was illuminating the spa and deck. After a while I climbed out of the spa and went to bed where I slept soundly until morning. I woke up with mi...