Gay Anal Plug Stories

4,340 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Fulfilling a Fantasy

by eagle122999 on Apr 3, 2019
Gay Male

Sex with a man. It's a fantasy some straight guys have but few act on it. For quite a while I have thought about going through with it. I didn't really have a fantasy guy picked out, except for one aspect... his cock. My fantasy guy had a big cock. I figured if I was going to go through with the fantasy I would go big or go home. I would talk to guys online...

The Hookup: Beginnings

by SemiStraight on Nov 18, 2019
Gay Male

Some of my stories are true, some have elements of truth, and some are pure fiction. This one falls into the true category and I haven't decided how much to admit yet. I keep a couple of the hookup sites on my hidden web browser. The thoughts of hooking up ebb and flow and occasionally I use the mail feature to communicate to all the guys who send smiles, w...

Church Volunteer Becomes BBC Sub

by Ewriter111 on Jul 27, 2020
Gay Male

There she was. My beautiful 5', 100 lb. blue eyed brunette wife bent over with a thick 10 inch black cock up her ass. Her pert little tits swinging side to side as her butthole was being stretched obscenely. A week earlier, I would have been mortified by this but I found out that things can change pretty quickly. I continued past our former marriage bed to t...

My First Big Black Cock

by babaca789 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This is my first submission, please let me know what you think! All comments are welcome :) ***** Well, I was about 18 years old and fresh out of high school. Horny as hell, constantly jerking my cock at porn, thinking about girls (I was actually pretty straight at this point) and trying to fuck as many girls as possible. I had hooked up with a few guys t...

Lubrication in the Tool Shed

by Cumfusion on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

It brought it all back to me but I never guessed anything like this would happen. Anyway you may have read Carl's first hand account of being caught with his pants down. Yea and that's an understatement. Anyway it was two years since I went on that biking holiday with Bobby and I had almost given up ever being able to fulfil what began that evening in the y...

The Game Bus Ch. 04

by darkfaded on Mar 2, 2020
Gay Male

**Station 4: The Hot Seat** Adam walked down the dark and narrow pathway and arrived upon a metal door. He reached out for the metal handle on the door and opened it, revealing nothing but darkness inside. He stepped into the room apprehensively, and the door behind him automatically shuts itself, leaving Adam in pitch darkness. Adam stretched out his han...

A Night Out and In!

by Wheelbearotx on Jan 7, 2019
Gay Male

I was just home from work and jumped in the shower. I was going to make a little dinner for myself once I rinsed off. Looking forward to a night of television and video games. I could entertain myself easily for the evening. Dad had a cocktail party for work later this evening, leaving me to my own devices... Or so I thought. I had just dried off when he wal...

Sequences Ch. 01

by luvkitten on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The Master came home from the slave market carrying a small cage. He carried it with ease, as if it wasn't heavy. He took it into the most secure cell in the house. This cell was completely soundproof. It was solid steel all the way around, protected by three steel doors, each with a different locking mechanism. There were cameras linked to a main room whi...

College Judo Ch. 05

by reddirtwriter on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

The three of us became a . . . well trio I guess. Shane and I paired up on a regular basis, and occasionally I got that itch that he scratched so well. Sometimes Shane would bring Marc, and he was always eager to play. His initial exposure to man-on-man sex might have been on the rough side, but he didn't seem to mind. There was a rhythm to it all and everyo...

A Secret Life Ch. 04

by ingarlm on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Note: I posted quite a short last chapter because I felt this bit needed to be on its own. I'm not quite sure why the story took this turn but I think it works so I've left it as first written. This chapter features fairly mild and consensual D/s with spanking and anal plugs. If that isn't your thing then you can skip to chapter 5 (the last one) which shoul...