Gay Anal Plug Stories

4,340 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Paying Dues

by Penisleeve2020 on Apr 21, 2020
Gay Male

INTRODUCTION Anyone could go to The Caves but there were a couple of areas where only the members could enter. I had always wanted to be a member after hearing some stories about the goings on. The Caves is a club in the city I live in. Over five floors of an old warehouse on the edge of the city centre a gay bathhouse, disco, bar club had developed. As lo...

A Wonderful Friendship Pt. 01

by cruiser5050 on Oct 31, 2018
Gay Male

Mike glanced at his watch outside of him home, seeing it was six am, thoughts came out as he started to walk, thinking this is a beautiful warm day. He went for a walk. day, and it will get warm threw out the day. Being sixty-five years old, in good shape from the gym is a good thing, but I still smoke cigarette and marijuana. Everyday I still think of my de...

Anal Peep Show

by wiley4377 on Oct 11, 2017
Gay Male

PEEP SHOW XXX ***It is not recommended to have unprotected sex with first time partners. I was first fascinated at a book with a variety of pictures of men fucking men and women. The anal intercourse was especially arousing.*** It started when I was 19 and for the next five years, I enjoyed anal intercourse with several men. Two men were regular visitors...

Paying Dues

by penisleeve on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

INTRODUCTION Anyone could go to The Caves but there were a couple of areas where only the members could enter. I had always wanted to be a member after hearing some stories about the goings on. The Caves is a club in the city I live in. Over five floors of an old warehouse on the edge of the city centre a gay bathhouse, disco, bar club had developed. As l...

Catching Up with an Old Friend Ch. 03

by jjdtx on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Scott walked over to the door, the butt plug inserted, wearing only his white stockings and opened it wide to let our guest in. "Wow!" He exclaimed, "You look great!" Scott replied, "Thanks, come on in." The guy we had met on CL walked into the room then saw me, sitting on the bed naked, my cock was about half hard. He introduced himself as Jim. He was w...

Alpha Male Ch. 03: Parents' Bedroom

by Royalboy_20 on Jul 24, 2018
Gay Male

It had been 2 days since Tyler had made a pass on Casey. Since then, Tyler and Casey had become inseparable. With Tyler donning the role of teacher in the bedroom, not only had Tyler popped Casey's anal and oral cherry, he had shown the young twink all sort of sex positions that rocked his world. Tyler had literally turned Casey's house into a sex cave. In...

My New Daddy Ch. 03

by sissytoy20 on Mar 6, 2018
Gay Male

The buttplug that Sam had unceremoniously forced inside my tight asscunt had hurt like hell, but I'd enjoyed the feeling of being forced open with no warning. The little, pink butt plug wasn't very large, but it had felt like a giant donkey dick in my ass. It had flashed by in Sam's hand so quickly, maybe it was larger than I thought. It felt huge in my butt...

Ballet School Ch. 05

by BigWig69 on Jan 23, 2019
Gay Male

Chapter Five-Beck and Call Jim stopped by at his usual time and told me to follow him. I got to his room and went inside and on the bed were a series of butt plugs, small to really big. Here's what we're going to do Chris. Because I know you are horny for cock in your ass all day long, we're going to keep that beautiful ass filled up and pulsating with pl...

Not So Boring Afternoon Ch. 03

by agpatch2 on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Quick recap: my first gay sex was getting gangbanged in an adult bookstore during spring break. My second time was a one on one with a guy I met through a glory hole the day I got back up to school. Here's the thing... So I'd been curious about sucking dick and getting fucked for a while and when I finally did it (and loved it) I went to the extreme. I ende...

Surprise at the Door

by Luckystiff2112 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This just happened to me today! But it all started last night. My buddy came over and we sat around shooting the breeze; took a ride in his hotrod- a '69 RoadRunner! Way cool! We came back and proceeded to get pretty drunk. So I fed him, gave him some water to sober him up some, and then he left. I was home alone now. My wife is away for the weekend, and wh...