Gay Anal Toys Stories

4,454 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Boy Hole

by caeneus on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

You'd never believe the story of how I fucked a guy for the first time. He was a drinking buddy, nearly twice my age and a head taller than me. I didn't know I was even interested until I transitioned from female to male. Suddenly I felt the dick and the drive that I had been missing all my life. The hormone therapy, testosterone, made me as horny as a tee...

Toying Around

by NineIsFine67 on Dec 10, 2018
Gay Male

Mark was the picturesque example of a family man. Good father of two teens, a hardworking provider and faithful husband of 22 years. He never cheated on his wife once although he had his opportunities. Although he was a handsome man and in great physical shape for a 41-year-old, he never once went behind his wife's back although he had been propositioned a c...

Teachers Pet

by Guy521 on Jun 5, 2019
Gay Male

It was a hot summer afternoon, when Nick arrived at Mr Jenkins house. He'd missed a lot of work over the past few weeks, but Mr Jenkins had offered to help him catch up. Checking his reflection in the door, one last time, Nick gave it a knock. A few moments later Mr Jenkins answered the door. He wore nothing but a pair of tight black shorts. Nick immediately...

Becoming Bi, Bit By Bit

by thinkmanthink on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The other day my girlfriend finally asked me, "Are you happy?" I was speechless. In that instant all the nagging impulses and desires I'd been experiencing over the last three years or so solidified in my heart and my soul screamed out. "No! Of course I'm not happy! We don't even fuck anymore, much less make love!" My mouth simply frowned diplomaticall...

Being with Greg

by alexcarr on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

It is always so nice being fucked by Greg and maybe that is an understatement, you see for me there has never been another to whom I have been so ardently chemically attracted and the moment we meet my whole being is a flutter in anticipation of the wonderful things to come. As on our first date he spoils and pampers me, wine and dines me at his local pub r...

Black Cock: 10 Inch Cock Training

by silkstockingslover on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Summary: Straight married man becomes a cocksucker and willing bottom. Note 1: This story is dedicated to goamz86 and to making one of his fantasies as real as possible. Note 2: Thanks to goamz86, Robert, and Wayne for editing this story. Note 3: Although this story is mostly a GAY interracial story, it is really a much deeper story about one man's len...

My First Male 3sum

by alibi on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

A while back I met this guy online (lets call him Rob) when I was looking for some male to male fun. While I love women, every now and then I just enjoy getting together with another guy. We hit it off immediately. He is in his 40s and divorced and Iā€™m in my 30s. We both love sucking and anal play and toys. Rob is about 6ā€™, 200lbs and sports a good 6-7ā€ cock...

How I Lost My Anal Virginity

by silverbullet2211 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This is a completely true story as to how I lost my anal virginity about a year ago. This is also my first time posting on here. Constructive criticism is more than welcomed. Hope you enjoy. ***** I had previous success with posting to Craigslist. I had met a few times before, but it was just for some oral play. Ever since I was eighteen I wanted to be fuc...

Fulfilling a Fantasy

by eagle122999 on Apr 3, 2019
Gay Male

Sex with a man. It's a fantasy some straight guys have but few act on it. For quite a while I have thought about going through with it. I didn't really have a fantasy guy picked out, except for one aspect... his cock. My fantasy guy had a big cock. I figured if I was going to go through with the fantasy I would go big or go home. I would talk to guys online...

My First Summer in Memphis

by talentedjack on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This is a true story. It is the story of a young man who was sheltered, unsophisticated about the world and not sure of himself. He came to Memphis from the countryside of Arkansas with no real experiences. It is about me. Growing up, I knew no real want. My parents were gainfully employed and made good money. I was the middle of five kids and did not get mu...