Gay Arm Wrestling Stories

10,477 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Learning to Score

by caughtsinning on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Edited by: MizTake - Thanks for all your help! ***** This was our second loss in row and the coach was pissed. He yelled at the entire team but the captain and I were the only ones he told to stay behind while everyone else went in the showers. "What's with you, Jackson??" The coach yelled at me. He could at least use my first name, Sam, like a normal pe...

Coach's Jock

by dirtyword on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I was on the wrestling team with Brody since we were in our sophomore year in high school. Brody was a good looking guy with big muscles in his legs, back and glutes. He wrestled in the 195 weight class and I was in the 160 weight class. We had grown to be good friends over the years. I admit I had sort of a bro-crush on Brody. I kept it to myself because I...

Wromocode Ch. 16

by HughGBabcock on Nov 2, 2020
Gay Male

Saturday, March 14 2:15PM CDT Little Rock, AR Drew Weeks Four of us from my team were going to nationals. Three of us had spent nearly all of our spare time together since the trip back from Birmingham on the bus. Four of us had been ridden hard in the daily practices we've had since regionals. Three of us had difficulty finding places to be alone togeth...

Finding True Love Pt. 03

by Beefyhungtopguy on Jan 16, 2019
Gay Male

We woke the next day and headed over to the church where Mack grew up. His parents had been members their entire lives and were holding a small luncheon of about 20 people to celebrate their anniversary. I met a few of his parent's friends, most of whom were polite and cordial, if not slightly scandalized by presence. Nonetheless, everyone was lovely and we...

Wrestling Buddies

by guybothways on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

My friend Jeff and I grew up on the same block. We did all the things teenage boys do. Our parents were good friends and once a week or so they got together to play cards and have a few drinks. We usually hung out at whatever house our parents weren't at. We were both eighteen year old seniors with a couple months or so before graduating from high school....

Jack Hammer Ch. 04

by KenJames on Jan 7, 2019
Gay Male

"Gentlemen!" Steve Steel addressed the crowd. "And you guys, too!" There were 107 men gathered around the wrestling mat in the big main room of Steel Steve's Global Health Club. Each had paid $250 to watch this event. Many had paid extra to do more than watch. The proceeds were going to a group of gay organizations. A dozen of the spectators were totally na...

I Used to be Straight Ch. 02

by NiceGuyInVa on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I rang the doorbell of Dave's Condo. It had been a week since our family reunion, and I had to see if it was just a fluke experience, or if there could be something more lasting between my 19 year old cousin and me. I was nervous as hell, worried that it had just been a passing fling for him, and after having me totally under his power in the shower, he wou...

Erotic Mud Battles: The Next Match

by mudwrestler on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

It had been a good two months since our last mud wrestle and Andy and I were keen to get together again. We had chatted constantly during this period. Keeping in touch and throwing ideas around for various other types of erotic messy wrestling. Everything from oil, custard, desserts, puddings, cake, baked beans, and the list seemed endless. As for the type...

My Cop Stud Neighbor

by NYCSTUD on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I'm a 26 year old, fairly good-looking and masculine man who developed such an intense crush on a stud police officer and neighbor of mine. This neighbor, James, lives three houses down, across the street with his attractive, blonde girlfriend and cute lab puppy. He is a young officer in our local town's force and also coached the local Babe Ruth baseball....

"C" Club Ch. 05

by dre_jones on Feb 12, 2019
Gay Male

In this 5th installment, Dre has sex with a hot young wrestler and then...well you'll find out. This is not a gay incest story. This work is fiction, and a product of the author's fevered imagination. Thanks again to my editor Bill. I love hearing from my readers so leave a comment or sent me a message. Enjoy! ***** All lanes slowed to a crawl, this was no...