Gay Arm Wrestling Stories

10,477 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

man vs man

by k-pounder on Sep 26, 2017
Gay

cough... cough the new guy just sits there looking at you with a sexual attraction. You are the recruiter for a new fighting league in Brooklyn, New York. Your the newest staff member and one of the only people who is not attracted to men. ""So argh... so you have any experience?"" you ask smiling not trying to get attacked by this guy. &...

Open in Reader

Erotic Oil Battle: Humiliation

by mudwrestler on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Be careful what you wish for! You probably know the rest of the saying. And yes, sometimes you do get it. I have been extremely lucky so far to have been able to indulge in what was once just a fantasy. Messy male erotic wrestling. I have had the pleasure of wrestling in a wondrous variety of substances and meeting a terrific selection of guys of all sha...

Sexy Wrestler

by taolanes on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

College wrestling is a tough sport. The practices are tough and dropping weight is a pain in the ass. Yet there was something I loved about it that I couldn't quite come to grips with. It all started with a weigh-in before the actual match. The way they work is that every guy on the team lines up one after the other with only their briefs on. Many want to s...

In Hot Water

by STLwriter on Aug 7, 2019
Gay Male

As sunlight beamed down onto the community pool, the water sparkled like tiny diamonds. Children laughed and played among one another while parents watched close by, either chatting in groups, or lounging on the poolside chairs. The concrete along the edge of the pool was littered with wet paw and hoof prints, evidence of people moving back and forth from sw...

Wolf's Alpha Status

by dchacha1 on Jul 4, 2018
Gay Male

Bing Bing.....Bing Bing. Aaron sat on the side of his bed, grimacing at the thought of checking the message on his phone. It had been a month since his tag team loss to Greg and Diego, and he and Matthew were no longer on speaking terms. Aaron had all but vanished from the underground wrestling scene and become a recluse. It was hard for him to accept that...

Erotic Mud Battle

by mudwrestler on Aug 28, 2017
Gay Male

The rain had stopped earlier in the morning and now the summer sun shone through the car windows heating the interior. I was hot already and wound down the window to let some cool air in. I was nervous. Even more than last time I travelled this way. Today was certainly going to be different. Only a few weeks ago I had participated in my first erotic mud...

New Discoveries Ch. 02

by unclduck69plus1 on Aug 17, 2017
Gay Male

Zander and I had just shared the most intense sexual experience, but we sat there playing our video game as if nothing had ever happened. We continued playing for a while when I spoke up. I said you know we really didn't settle anything yet when it comes to who's taking Lesley out. He said I know and pounced right back on me saying we needed to finish our wr...

The Handyman Ch. 04: 1815

by sr71plt on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

He felt the weight of his body pulling on his wrists where they were chained to the wall in the dungeon of the ritter's castle. His cheek rested against the clammy stone wall of the chamber. Still, though, the sweat was dripping down his brow and into his eyes. There was nothing he could do about that now. Von Rostock had left him, saying he'd be back after...

Getting . . . Educated Ch. 05

by sr71plt on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

After delivering me from jail and imprisoning me again in his web, Coach Seeman delivered me to Nate's door, ravished and still in handcuffs, which had been moved so that my arms were in front of me, and with my jeans barely covering me. When Nate answered the door, he was wearing only his briefs. As the dorm counselor, he had an actual one-bedroom apartme...

Down for the Count

by hisbigness on Aug 16, 2017
Gay Male

His massive forearms slowly tightened like a vise across my head, cutting off the supply of oxygen rich blood to my brain. I tried to break the hold to no avail, and next thing I knew, the gym slowly faded out... I awoke I don't know how much later, but Zach was gone. I had a pretty good headache going and a bitter taste in my mouth. And not just from losin...