Gay Butt Plug Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com

Master Jakob and Seth Ch. 09

by and9993 on Aug 13, 2018
Gay Male

After putting my butt plug in I went back upstairs. I hit the app on my phone which reinflated it to the last setting by Master. He warned me about the soreness and he was right. I had never felt this type of internal soreness before. Even my dick felt like I had spent the last hour cumming. Although I wanted to take advil, I understood where Master was comi...

Dave and Scott Pt. 04

by willowview43 on Sep 14, 2020
Gay Male

Scott had rammed a huge butt plug in my ass while we watched my brother get fucked by his son, and told me to keep it inside me all night. He wanted my asscunt loose ready for a hard fucking the next morning. I went back to my bed but I didn't sleep much that night - the plug was so big I could feel it stretching my hole. A tight cockring was around my cock...

Plugged

by dthrnd on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Josh is smiling to himself, just leaning against the wall and appreciating the familiar full feeling. A nightly occurrence, or at least every night they had a show. They're on in a couple minutes. Dan is standing next to him, drumming absently on the wall. "Ready?" Dan remarks, and Josh nods. "As always," he says. Josh nudges up against the wall, feeling t...

Adult Video Store

by bisuffolkguy on Apr 17, 2019
Gay Male

So I've come along way since my ass stretcher butt plug and dildo play. I use an extra-large butt plug daily, and have begun aggressively stretching my ass every chance I get. Dildos have progressed to large vegetables such as butternut squash and water bottles like Core and Smart Water. Its amazing with enough lube, you can get just about anything up your a...

Catching Up with an Old Friend Ch. 03

by jjdtx on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Scott walked over to the door, the butt plug inserted, wearing only his white stockings and opened it wide to let our guest in. "Wow!" He exclaimed, "You look great!" Scott replied, "Thanks, come on in." The guy we had met on CL walked into the room then saw me, sitting on the bed naked, my cock was about half hard. He introduced himself as Jim. He was w...

The Hanky Code Pt. 10

by His_fag_wife on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I was still strapped to the bench and completely helpless, the electric butt plug fucking my pussy steadily and the weights from my long extended nipples swinging gently on the end of my huge D size saline injected tits. My moans were steady and constant, those of a complete pig in pure sexual heaven. I was in my perfect place, wallowing in the degradation a...

Daddy's Little Butt Boy Pt. 02

by rae121452 on Aug 22, 2018
Gay Male

*This story contains scenes of gay incest.* ***** It had gotten to the point where I hated to leave home in the morning and couldn't wait to get back at night. In between, my dick stayed permanently half hard from thinking about my son, Bobby. His ass hole was insatiable, always willing and able to have my big dick penetrate it. Since I had started fucki...

Becoming a Gal Friday Pt. 10

by Showoff888 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I'm dressed in my 'Fuck me' backless platform pink six inch high heels, and nothing else, having stripped off the denim Daisy Duke cut offs, the sweatshirt and even the white string thong that was holding in my butt plug. I'm all made up with long lashes, mascara, and pink lipstick, whispering in my white bosses ear to please fuck me. I had previously been...

Becoming a Gal Friday Pt. 09

by Showoff888 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Here I am standing naked in red 6 inch plastic high heel platform shoes, all dolled up in makeup with red lipstick and sporting a semi-erect cock being held in a fabric cock ring thong that is also holding a penis shaped butt plug in my ass. I am in my Ex's apartment complex in the morning hours with David in an elevator. I feel so vulnerable and so much l...

Becoming a Gal Friday Pt. 08

by Showoff888 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Here I am in the front seat of my bosses SUV, naked wearing only a pair of pink platform high heels. My feet are spread wide with those heels sitting on the dashboard. I have this plastic cock butt plug nestled in my ass, and I am sporting my fully aroused erections that my boss, David has oiled for me. We are driving to my Ex's place to get my stuff out of...