Gay Butt Plug Stories

7,789 results
Infinite Scroll

The Start Ch. 02

by bisubhubby on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

In Part 1, I told the story of how I sucked my first cock. Part 2 relates how I moved very quickly to find out what being a real bisexual meant by getting fucked by a man. I just had to know what it felt like to have a cock sliding in and out of me. I asked Ron (whom I had just sucked) if he would like to fuck me but he said he was not into fucking men. He...

Ballet School Ch. 05

by BigWig69 on Jan 23, 2019
Gay Male

Chapter Five-Beck and Call Jim stopped by at his usual time and told me to follow him. I got to his room and went inside and on the bed were a series of butt plugs, small to really big. Here's what we're going to do Chris. Because I know you are horny for cock in your ass all day long, we're going to keep that beautiful ass filled up and pulsating with pl...

An English Boy Gets Turned Out Ch. 05

by RustyRover on Jul 17, 2018
Gay Male

I am sorry for the delay in posting chapter 5, life and writers block got in the way. * Normally when I wake up I need to take a pee. But this morning it felt like I needed to take a dump. That feeling woke me up with a start as I recalled my ass was full of butt plug. Then the memories came flooding back. Instantly my heart starting beating faster, my che...

A Morning in Bed

by st3ph1066 on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I was lay in my bed on an early, wet Monday morning. My thoughts started to wander to the guy I had met on the previous Friday night, my hands trailed down my chest as I thought about his fantastic body, and his big 8 inch cock, his clean shaven balls and his hot sexy ass. My hand reached my already stiffening cock, my fingers started to trace lines across...

Old Man Discovers... Ch. 10

by tnwriter on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

last sentence of chapter 9.. take your mind off.... * Sitting across from Fred, on the couch I think..WOW!! Tits and ass, instead of tits and pussy? With a little cock thrown in? My mind started racing back to all our other encounters. Just a couple of old guys having sex? Would I ever have sex with a woman? Was I gay or bi? Fred did say maybe someday a c...

Giving Up Control Ch. 01

by funguy2223 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Walking to the front door of your condo I notice the door is cracked and there is a note outside. The note reads "I expect you to be fully shaved and wearing your cock ring. I expect you to remain silent the entire time you are here except when you are gagging on my cock or my dildo. I expect you to enter my condo and close the door, then strip entirely nake...

An Old Friend Ch. 02

by jjdtx on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter 2 – The Next Day The next morning, Joe left early for work and I didn't have an appointment until late in the day. So, I lounged around, looking at his DVD collection. In a small box, I found his porn stash. It was a nice selection of compilation DVD's. About twenty in all, most were straight cum shot movies, but there were four bi movies. All were...

A Contractor's Unpaid Invoice

by wilcox010 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

Warning: this story contains nonconsensual themes. * My name is James Francis and the following story is true and one that I have found to be continually on my mind sense that fateful early summer day. I am 42 years old, married to my beautiful wife Jane who is a flight attendant, two college age children, own a very nice house, two fancy cars and have a...

Can A Straight Boy Be Turned Ch. 03

by Liquid_Dreamsxxx on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Friday March 27th A couple of weeks had passed since the Joe incident. Things had changed even if I didn't want to confess it for myself. I had watched gay porn this week. I had never done that before. I had thought about Joe and got aroused, switched on my computer and watched gay porn, but only one time! After I had watched gay porn I felt so ashamed....

Catching Up with an Old Friend Ch. 03

by jjdtx on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Scott walked over to the door, the butt plug inserted, wearing only his white stockings and opened it wide to let our guest in. "Wow!" He exclaimed, "You look great!" Scott replied, "Thanks, come on in." The guy we had met on CL walked into the room then saw me, sitting on the bed naked, my cock was about half hard. He introduced himself as Jim. He was w...