Gay Butt Plug Punishment Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Category
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com
Create your own smut fantasy with AI

A Real Bathhouse Slut is Made

by Danmo1 on Sep 16, 2017
Gay Male

This true account of the activities of a mature 50'ish guy continues from my first time at a bathhouse entitled The Making of a Real Bathhouse Slut. As I drove home from the bathhouse the first week I had a hundred different things going through my head, one of which was guilt. I quickly realized that after years of no sex with my wife there was really noth...

Bound and In Love Ch. 02

by Baby789 on Sep 26, 2017
Gay Male

This story contains BDSM and bondage material please do not continue to read if you do not like that kind of thing. Thank you for reading, comments and ratings are appreciated. * "What's this?" Michael fingered the odd shaped toy; it was cool to touch and made of red rubber, with a wide bottom, a cord from the bottom and a wireless control next to it. "It...

The Ascension of Will Ch. 02

by Varla_Pussycat on Sep 17, 2017
Gay Male

Will was once again locked in the cage. He stared blankly at the ceiling, not really thinking about anything. He was pleased that he was at least allowed to have some books to read. Though by now, he'd already read them several times. They had also removed the chastity device only out of necessity...he kept getting sores from where it rubbed against his skin...

Breaking Lance Ch. 06

by martin_x59 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

At the car the parking lot is deserted, "Ok strip," Vince says. "What? Out he.... OWW!" Vince swipes him hard across his ass. "Don't question my orders boy. Just do it!" Vince barks. Reluctantly Lance strips and hands his clothes to Vince who puts them in the back of the car. Vince then removes the butt plug and cock ring from Lance but puts a much bigger...

First Taste of Cock

by Rocket19 on Sep 2, 2017
Gay Male

My latest bondage creation has got to be my finest. It has all the components necessary to make both the slave and the master very happy. I started with some square tube steel; forming it into an upside down "Y" with a crossbar two thirds of the way up the leg of the Y. Both the crossbar and the leg of my inverted Y are adjustable to allow for the height of...

An English Boy Gets Turned Out Ch. 04

by RustyRover on Oct 13, 2017
Gay Male

I woke up late on Saturday morning and luxuriated in the knowledge I had no work for university or the book store for 2 whole days. As I was coming to, I felt a slight soreness in my ass and that reminded me I had to watch and study gay porn. Perhaps it wasn't going to be such a great weekend after all. I started to replay the events of last night and remem...

An English Boy Gets Turned Out Ch. 05

by RustyRover on Jul 17, 2018
Gay Male

I am sorry for the delay in posting chapter 5, life and writers block got in the way. * Normally when I wake up I need to take a pee. But this morning it felt like I needed to take a dump. That feeling woke me up with a start as I recalled my ass was full of butt plug. Then the memories came flooding back. Instantly my heart starting beating faster, my che...

Workout Buddies Ch. 03

by 60031Guy on Dec 10, 2018
Gay Male

Workout Buddies: Day 2 of Paying Off the Bet (c) 2018. All rights reserved. _____ Author's note Hi there, thanks for taking the time to read this story. Please let me know what you think. This is my second story submitted anywhere, and is a continuation of, Workout Buddies, Chapter 1, The Bet. Folks seemed interested in the first chapter, so this is the...

Workout Buddies Ch. 04

by 60031Guy on Jan 1, 2019
Gay Male

Author's note Hi there, thanks for taking the time to read this story. Please let me know what you think. This is the fourth chapter in my Workout Buddies story. This story contains scenes of M/M, M/F, MMF, oral, anal, dominant/submissive sex, cock sucking, butt plug, and cum eating. If that offends you, please don't read. Support The site you are readi...

Ben is Kept Under Control Ch. 03

by verdunsears on Mar 12, 2019
Gay Male

I'd met Marco, a curious straight boy and Robert, a stern older man, at a party at my friend Carlo's place. I'd given Marco a blow job after the party and the next Robert had fucked me and pissed down my throat, then left me tied up with a butt plug up my ass while he went out bar hopping with Carlo. He left me feeling incredibly frustrated and horny as he...