Gay Butt Plug Punishment Stories

8,505 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Now or Never: Escape to Freedom Ch. 02

by CE300 on Sep 26, 2017
Gay Male

As always, this story is completely fiction and any likeness to real events or people are completely coincidental. My stories contain a lot of detail and dialogue so if you're looking for a short to the point story this is not for you. If you looking for a story that contains suspense, drama and adventure than this is it! This chapter contains an extreme sit...

Chad and Blaine Ch. 06

by Baby789 on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Dean smiled as he dropped Blaine into the back seat of his rusted brown truck, there was a hole the size of his head in the rear door and as he slammed it closed more metal fell off onto the floor. His cock ached as he thought of all the things him and Blaine were going to do before the week was finished. That's even if he wakes up, a small voice in the back...

Destined Hearts Ch. 08

by vanalas on Mar 12, 2019
Gay Male

Comments, critiques and tips are welcome. Welcome to this lovely chapter of one of your favorite stories. I would like to thank you guys for making this story a big success, even better than I imagined. Both of my ongoing stories, "Wild Flower" and "Destined Hearts" are going successfully and it is because of you guys and your love. I am back to school now...

The Bottle and the Bi-Curious

by Vaginalpuppetry on Jul 24, 2018
Gay Male

This story is a work of fantasy, though based largely on missed opportunities. It is categorized as Gay Male, but is mainly about exploring bisexuality in a MMF threesome, and includes heterosexual sex. This is my first time writing this kind of story, so I do apologize if it's not up to par. Still, I hope you enjoy my fantasy as much as I've enjoyed writing...

Of All the Little Coffee Shops. . .

by EventualRain on Oct 3, 2018
Gay Male

'No , no, no,' I thought frantically 'Not today, not today of all days'. He was here, my french vanilla dream man. In all his gorgeous glory, he was here. And I was a mess, a literal hot mess. It was the hottest day of summer so far and the air conditioner had blown ten minutes after I arrived to start my shift at the coffee shop I co-owned with my best frie...

Field of Blooms: The Beginning Ch. 04

by CE300 on May 16, 2018
Gay Male

The moment you've all been waiting for, Chapter 4 of Field of Blooms: Walking the Halls. As always my stories are gay themed and contain gay sex, except this chapter. Yes, I know you all are crush that there isn't any sex in this chapter. This is a building block chapter that really helps develop the story, don't worry I will make up for the lack of sex in t...

The Invitation

by harding on Mar 20, 2018
Gay Male

A brief warning for anyone who had read some of my other contributions and might be expecting more of the same here. Please note the category – Gay Male. This is an experiment. Yes, there is a female involved, but it is primarily about the love of one man for another. Take of it what you will. If it's your thing I hope you enjoy it. If it's not, there are pl...

Curious No More Ch. 10

by bicurve on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Thank you for your patience! I really appreciate all your emails and support. But enough about me; let's get to the stuff you men want. * "Are you looking forward to getting your ass used and filled?" I pushed my crotch into him, my hard cock apparent. "Does that answer your question?" "Let's get dressed and get some food. Alex and Cory are going to call...

Janus

by eliotmoore on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

In Roman mythology, Janus (or Ianus) was the god of gates, doors, doorways, beginnings and endings. *** Sunset 9:15 PM *** The soft yellow sun touched the black horizon. A solitary bluff of poplars broke the wavering line marking land and sky. Seaborg's Trees marked the traditional party spot. Michael took a sip of coffee and checked reflexively for the te...

Darren & Dean do Dale Ch. 03

by betamale08 on Aug 7, 2019
Gay Male

After we had our steaks, which were perfect I might add. I did clean up again, donning my apron over my top and mini-skirt, where again I was playing little miss homemaker for the two men Darren and Dean while they sat out having coffee and then joining them once I was finished, I came back out to them with three beers, one for each of us this time. I didn't...