Gay Butt Plug Punishment Stories

8,505 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Always, Forever and a Day Ch. 02

by Baby789 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

If you haven't read The Day It All Changed and Always Forever and a Day please read them first. Thank you feedback appreciated. * Tyler groaned and sighed, stretching as he woke up, he stomach cramped and he was soaked with his own sweat. "How are you, Tiger?" Matt murmured next to his ear. Tyler had came down with a bad case of the flu and Matt had been...

Connor on Campus Ch. 03

by JasonClearwater on Nov 1, 2017
Gay Male

* * Stan gets to know Darren, and Connor punishes Stan * * Wrapped in Stan's arms, Darren drifts. In all the years he's dreamt of finding a boyfriend, of having sex, of having someone to care about him, what's happened in the last two days is doing his head in. He'd always hoped his first time would be special, with someone he really liked—but with Connor...

My Asian Master: Tested Twice

by Bootlick on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Master was not ready to take me as his slave. He subjected me to two tests. The first was my ability to obey. I knelt. He handed me a black jockstrap, a white handkerchief and a blue cloth napkin. All three were stiff with semen stains. I learned that these items were prepared from the Master's cum by his previous sub. My orders, for the next three days, wer...

Demands on Him Ch. 03

by latenightkiss on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I stared at my boss, dumbfounded by his presence on my doorstep. It had been more than a week since I'd seen him, and I certainly hadn't invited him to my house for tonight's party. The last thing I wanted was to ring in my New Year with the reason for all my hard-ons this week. "Gonna let me in, baby boy?" I stepped out onto the porch, closing the door be...

Swimsuit Shopping Pt. 02 - Cocktails

by Johnthong1989 on Sep 21, 2020
Gay Male

I woke up a little hazy. Unsure if last night really happened. I didn't believe it until I felt how sore my jaw was. My mouth had never been put through anything like that before. The night was confirmed again once I saw the anal lube, butt plug and skimpy black thong sitting on the table. I read the note again and tossed it in the bin, wondering who that gu...

Church Volunteer Becomes BBC Sub

by Ewriter111 on Jul 27, 2020
Gay Male

There she was. My beautiful 5', 100 lb. blue eyed brunette wife bent over with a thick 10 inch black cock up her ass. Her pert little tits swinging side to side as her butthole was being stretched obscenely. A week earlier, I would have been mortified by this but I found out that things can change pretty quickly. I continued past our former marriage bed to t...

Farm Boi Life Ch. 03

by Sungmehetu on Feb 6, 2018
Gay Male

Sorry for the long absence. As this was the most requested sequel, I made sure Ryan's adventure to be the first now that I have spare time to write again. ALL Characters are over 18. ***** I had to strip the sheets the following morning and found two slaves kneeling outside the bedroom door as I carried the damp, sticky bundle. "Alpha Chef, we will take...

An English Boy Gets Turned Out Ch. 05

by RustyRover on Jul 17, 2018
Gay Male

I am sorry for the delay in posting chapter 5, life and writers block got in the way. * Normally when I wake up I need to take a pee. But this morning it felt like I needed to take a dump. That feeling woke me up with a start as I recalled my ass was full of butt plug. Then the memories came flooding back. Instantly my heart starting beating faster, my che...

Workout Buddies Ch. 03

by 60031Guy on Dec 10, 2018
Gay Male

Workout Buddies: Day 2 of Paying Off the Bet (c) 2018. All rights reserved. _____ Author's note Hi there, thanks for taking the time to read this story. Please let me know what you think. This is my second story submitted anywhere, and is a continuation of, Workout Buddies, Chapter 1, The Bet. Folks seemed interested in the first chapter, so this is the...

First Taste of Cock

by Rocket19 on Sep 2, 2017
Gay Male

My latest bondage creation has got to be my finest. It has all the components necessary to make both the slave and the master very happy. I started with some square tube steel; forming it into an upside down "Y" with a crossbar two thirds of the way up the leg of the Y. Both the crossbar and the leg of my inverted Y are adjustable to allow for the height of...