Gay Butt Plug Punishment Stories

8,505 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Daddy's Boy Ch. 04: New Normal

by ashlaurchamp on Jun 1, 2020
Gay Male

"Rise and shine, whore." Was the first sound that I woke too in the morning. At first, I didn't know where I was or remember anything that had happened in the past couple of days. I groggily lifted my head off of my mattress, feeling a pressure all the way around my neck and also inside of my ass. I shifted on my bed, feeling my anus probed further. "Ow, o...

The New Slave Ch. 03

by martin_x59 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I would like to start by saying I am new to writing so I hope you don't judge me too hard on my literary naivety. Nor am I experienced in Bondage or Master Slave relationships. This story is pure fantasy from my part and is about what I find erotic and stimulating. Please bear this in mind when reading the story. I hope you find it as stimulating reading as...

An English Boy Gets Turned Out Ch. 03

by RustyRover on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Mr Tobias was at work earlier than normal today. He had an early meeting with Mick to discuss the new star of their porn website. The Porn industry used to be a license to print money but that had changed over the last few years. Now there was more free porn available than paid for porn. Between Porno YouTubes knock offs, torrents and all these other sites e...

Chase Becomes Chaste Ch. 03

by growing_interest on Aug 22, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter synopsis: Our narrator expands Chase's hell beyond his home, Chase's new wardrobe beyond the one jockstrap, and Chase's virgin asshole beyond its normal size. ********* "I'm not going out like this!" How long was it going to take Chase to figure out that he didn't have a choice? I wasn't "asking" him to do anything. I was telling him. "Come on, m...

Bitch Dick Twitch

by cockmachine on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

First duty of the day. I slide my shaved-smooth body nimbly from the sheets and tip toe into the bathroom. I quickly take care of any errant stubble and look myself up and down in the mirror. I am 19, skinny, about 5'10" with short brown hair and blue eyes. Aside from the slightly-too small lace thong I am wearing, I am nude. That is, if you don't include a...

Encounter

by little sebastian on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

My well lubed bunghole was an inch from the head of my 9.5x5.5" silicone toy and I would literally collapse onto it as forced it's way deep into my body. Pleasure would ripple through me causing my nipples to become hard. I would ride it's length with abandon, drops of perspiration ran down the small of my back as I fucked it to a state of breathlessness. My...

First Punishment

by kinkfiction on Jan 16, 2019
Gay Male

"You disappointed me, baby boy. I know you didn't mean to, and I'll forgive you. But first I need to show you the true extent of my unhappiness. You've been such a good boy up till now but I can't let you think that you can get away with this behavior. You disobeyed me when you went against my instructions. I get that you don't understand why it's such a big...

The Hanky Code Pt. 11

by His_fag_wife on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

They continued to play cards and laugh and joke, but I was only vaguely aware of that on the periphery of my consciousness. The Cyborg cock in my ass pussy was all consuming, the way it had been positioned, with the cock 2 inches in my ass, the neck of the head which was only 6 inches or so around was just inside me and the small movements meant the ridge o...

Fawned - A PetPlay Romance Ch. 08

by WinterPior on Mar 30, 2020
Gay Male

"Bee?" "Hm?" "Are you okay?" "Y-Yeah...Why?" "You're getting soft." Barnaby frowned, and he reluctantly opened his eyes to see Gil retracting a hand from his cock. The man's brows were knitted together, and Barnaby worried he might think he did something wrong. "I'm sorry," he muttered, fixing the backpack-turned-pillow behind his head. He moved his fo...

A Visit to the Spa 02 - Nick Pt. 03

by Tarash on Jun 18, 2019
Gay Male

Nick was having a quick lunch with a couple of the other massage therapists at the spa, talking about the treatments they had given so far that day, and exchanging a few tips. He was still the newest member of the team, but he was definitely starting to fit in and enjoyed hanging out with the others. Ryan came over to them. The older man was the head of sec...