Gay Butt Plug Stories

7,789 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Owned

by bttplglvr on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

My name is Mark, until today I lived pretty much an average life. I am happily married for many years with grown up children. I am self-employed and work from home, my wife has a good paying job at an insurance company. We are not rich but what I would consider comfortable. Recently I have been getting I guess you would call it curious about certain male/ma...

My First Time Fantasy Ch. 02

by imnot2serious on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Well, since I'm being honest, I need to tell you my deepest fantasy... I was involved with a woman named Jodi. It was a brief relationship which we both wanted to last but certain outside forces put an end to that. We still text from time to time. The sex life we had is still a topic of conversation for us. One thing she wants to do, if/when we hook up agai...

Fantasy Fulfilled

by schuwinggg on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

As always, comments and feedback are warmly appreciated! * For three days I had been so stressed out, I was afraid I'd blow a gasket. Well, I hoped to blow something soon, anyway. Less than seventy-two hours before I had taken the plunge and went to a gay bar with all intentions of fulfilling my biggest fantasy. Being straight all my life, yet recently qu...

The Hanky Code Pt. 15

by His_fag_wife on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Mistress Caprice stood in front of me and looked deep into my glazed eyes, as I rocked up and down on my rubber cock. "I had to pay a pretty penny for you bitch, after so many people had watched some of your more extreme videos. A lot of very depraved people could see just how much use you might be." "But I wanted you before your inevitable trip to the far...

The Hanky Code Pt. 08

by His_fag_wife on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

A round of applause went through the room accompanied by some cheering. It seemed I had done well as Masters' pig. As I squatted, completely spent, with my ass pussy completely filled by the huge barrel, filled with nearly 2lbs of rubber, not just stretching my actual pussy but also my insides. My lips still covered in cum and piss, I was still involuntaril...

Influencer to Sex Slave Ch. 05

by dreamymark9 on Jul 30, 2019
Gay Male

Author's note: This is erotic fantasy and completely fictional. The main character, Jack, is a fictional, generic social media star / influencer, and is not a real person. As always, would love to get feedback in comments and messages. Today was Jack's first day as a sex slave when his master was at work, and it was pretty eventful. He got a ton of embarras...

Straight to Bi, Cam to Real Life

by dlcalguy on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

After I finished university, I struggled for a good-paying job and money was tight. But I couldn't face living back at home. I managed to find a room to myself in a house-share with two other guys and three women. We were mostly in our early twenties and doing various entry-level jobs. One guy, Pete, was older. About 45. He was on a temporary assignment in o...

Straight Man Cums in Gay Massage

by Rosko Busby 2005 on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

Shane explodes in Special Gay Massage for Straights The five of us who ran the local gym were all gay and regular sex partners. We had shared many group sessions where we pretended to capture one of the group and subject him to fucking and torture. One of the fantasies we shared though was to do this for real and to force a good looking straight chap into j...

The Shed - John's Story

by fatherfucks on Jul 4, 2018
Gay Male

It was about 10 in the morning when Mom suggested that I cross the field to our new neighbors to invite him over to dinner. He has moved in a couple of weeks earlier and frankly Mom was hoping to find him "eligible". We had heard that he was newly retired and in his early sixties. I thought that was a little old for Mom; after all she was in her early 40s. B...

Charley Gives It Up

by ndeavour on Oct 16, 2018
Gay Male

Charley was more than a little bit nervous. He was -- if he were to admit it - a little bit scared. And, at the same time, he was as excited as he'd ever been in his life. Whatever the feeling was called, he was in love with it. It was the same feeling when he'd first visited the local Adult Books Store (as they used to call it) and discovered the glory hole...