Gay Butt Plug Stories

7,789 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

The Hanky Code Pt. 18

by His_fag_wife on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I was fast asleep, dreaming such sinful, delightful dreams when I felt my hands and ankles being restrained. Then I felt a heavy body sit astride me and it pulled down hard, forcing a ball gag into my mouth. I tried to resist but my teeth would have been smashed. The ball gag pushed into my mouth and my head was lifted as it was buckled tightly behind me,...

Jack's First Time

by JakeLogan13 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

Jack always had been curious about bi-experiences, but never had a chance to try it out. He was 30 years old and had several girlfriends. However, what drew him to trying out a gay experience was more of a power game of giving up control and being "forced" to do something forbidden. One day he even put up a craigslist, but never went through with it. This d...

First Time With a Vengeance

by rag23 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

I’d never been with another guy before, and until a few months ago, I wouldn’t have believed it was ever something that would happen to me. I’m very happily heterosexual, and although I was occasionally curious about what it would be like to suck a cock, I never thought I would be curious enough to do anything about it. It all started, really, with a dream....

Surprised and Used Again

by Ryter on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Just when I thought that nothing would happen, on the thirteenth day after my trip to Birmingham, a text arrived at around 8.30 pm saying "Hope to see you at 6.30 pm tomorrow at the same place or will contact as previously notified." This was a veiled threat that to anyone else would have appeared innocuous. A further message arrived shortly after saying "J...

The Boy At My Door... Ch. 03

by funguy2223 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

It's been ten days since this teen boy first knocked at my door. I remember when I first looked through the peephole to see proof that he was legal and had shaven his thin eighteen year old body for me. He was such an innocent boy in that first moment, so horny and so inexperienced. How was he to know that what I had been doing to him was anything other than...

My Angry Tenants Ch. 07

by rae121452 on Oct 11, 2017
Gay Male

It was the day I had to fly to Buffalo and I was a little bit uncomfortable. Ron and Gary had given me a going away party the night before and invited Johnson and Ken, the parole duo and the massive dicked tattoo guy who did their ink. Which meant that they had run a train, all night long, on my now bruised and throbbing asshole. My jaw felt like it was di...

Gentlemen's Club Ch. 12

by Ywashere on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Sorry for the wait (don't you hate it when real life gets in the way) - here's a little something while I polish off the next character story. Y All characters are 18 or older. SHOWTIME The curtains pulled back to reveal a tall, muscular, blond young man on a haystack (the haystack was actually foam rubber covered with a hay-patterned cloth, but no one...

I Hate My Master Ch. 18

by maxpotter on Aug 26, 2019
Gay Male

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of non-consensual or reluctant sex. ***** Timmy fucked me twice, got blown, and had my tongue working on him the rest of the time. All while playing his game. I was worn out. He didn't care how tough this was on me, just that he was feeling good. I didn't know if it would ever end. He got a text, checked his phon...

Prepping for My New Life

by schuwinggg on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Here I was, jilted by the girl I had devoted the last 10 years to and wondering what I did wrong and how I would trust a woman ever again. All during that time my partner had a fixation with my ass and I was slowly but surely questioning my leanings. It all started with her eating out my rear and progressing to the point that I couldn't cum unless she was r...

Daytime Fun between Tim and Bill

by Hawkeye1981 on Mar 13, 2018
Gay Male

Tim got home from work. He called out to his mom. "Mom!" No answer. He walked into the kitchen and saw a note. "Tim I'm going out after work I will be home later. Hope your day was good... Mom" Tim smiled thinking about lunch with Bill. He still felt the fire in his stomach for him. Tim changed into some shorts and wandered to his moms room. His feet...