Gay Butt Plug Stories

7,789 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Becoming a Gal Friday Pt. 09

by Showoff888 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Here I am standing naked in red 6 inch plastic high heel platform shoes, all dolled up in makeup with red lipstick and sporting a semi-erect cock being held in a fabric cock ring thong that is also holding a penis shaped butt plug in my ass. I am in my Ex's apartment complex in the morning hours with David in an elevator. I feel so vulnerable and so much l...

The New Slave Ch. 03

by martin_x59 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I would like to start by saying I am new to writing so I hope you don't judge me too hard on my literary naivety. Nor am I experienced in Bondage or Master Slave relationships. This story is pure fantasy from my part and is about what I find erotic and stimulating. Please bear this in mind when reading the story. I hope you find it as stimulating reading as...

A Familiar Story Ch. 02

by canacoc on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

If you like this second part of this true story, please vote and let me know your opinions. * Four nights before I had received a fabulous blow job from a late blooming first-timer and knew I had to explore this eager beaver a bit further. I have been living with a great guy and haven't fooled around on him the whole time together, but by prior arrangemen...

Demands on Him Ch. 02

by latenightkiss on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

"Will, honey, will you make sure there's plenty of ice in the cooler?" Jenna called from the kitchen. I checked my watch and saw that it was almost time for our guests to arrive. The New Year's Eve party had been Jenna's idea three years ago when we'd first moved in together, and it had evolved into a tradition. Jenna had spent the last two days cleaning an...

Demands on Him Ch. 02

by secretkkisses on May 15, 2019
Gay Male

Again, this story thread was previously published under my old username, latenightkiss, which I no longer have access to. Once the old thread has been published I will add new chapters! ***** "Will, honey, will you make sure there's plenty of ice in the cooler?" Jenna called from the kitchen. I checked my watch and saw that it was almost time for our gue...

How I Became A Cock Slave Ch. 04

by bearlover1689 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

That long night was the most beautiful night of my life as Mike drilled my ass reletlesly, leaving enough sperm in my ass to repopulate the earth. After that I moved in to his place and lived with Mike and his roommates for the rest of the year, only going back to my dorm room when my parents were in town. Although Mike was the only one aloud to use my ass h...

Influencer to Sex Slave Ch. 06

by dreamymark9 on Dec 24, 2019
Gay Male

Author's note: This is erotic fantasy and completely fictional. The main character, Jack, is a fictional, generic social media star / influencer, and is not a real person. Apologizes I haven't written in a while, but thanks for the comments and messages. They really give me ideas and encourage me to keep going! ***** Jack reflects on how he went from being...

My Daughter's Boyfriend Pt. 02

by Yman67 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I didn't see much of Fred for a few weeks, except for around the neighborhood. I was thinking of him quite often, but I wanted him to come back only if he wanted to. Spring was in full bloom and Alice and Melanie were gone out of town for the weekend to visit my mother-in-law. I was working a new shift and was unable to go, so on the weekend I stuck around t...

The Lawn Rangers Ch. 07

by texaswade on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The day after our visit to the adult bookstore, John came over to help me start stretching my asshole. I had decided it was time to let him fuck me in the ass. My parents were both at work, and my brother was at school. John knocked on the door, and I answered it already naked. John looked really excited. He was ready to help me use the dildos. "We can...

Boat Ho Ch. 11

by rckplsky on Sep 15, 2017
Gay Male

"Any plans for tonight," Alex asked Huff as they broke from muster. "Don't know," he replied, "I might go to a club." "I didn't know you were 21," she laughed. "I'm not 21," he replied. "Shut up," she said back. "Okay," he laughed, "I am." "What club," she asked. "It's near downtown," he replied. "Cool," she replied, "I may catch a movie down there."...