Gay Butt Plug Stories

7,789 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

My Roommate's Toy Box Ch. 03

by brycemanning on Sep 14, 2020
Gay Male

As the hours ticked away that night, I steadily grew more worried that Alex might snap on me and freak out again at any moment. He'd showed me his biggest secrets, touched my dick, and busted twice, all the horniness temporarily drained out of both of us. I anxiously imagined him glancing over, realizing I was still naked, maybe looking down at my dick and r...

Latter Day Sinners

by walterio on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Jack Jenson was in his office on a rainy Saturday morning looking at porn on his computer. He had been rained out his golf game and had decided to chill out with a cup of coffee and check the newly posted free porn. He liked watching European porn where beautiful babes with natural bodies did it all. He loved watching guys with big cocks like his stick them...

Initiated Ch. 03

by GulfCoastGuy84 on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

He savored the sight of me, cum all over my face, then had me take a shower. When I had dried off, he installed a butt plug inside me- he didn't ask my permission, he simply did it, and I loved it. Then he put a jock strap on me and had me get dressed again in the tiny swim trunks. He also put aviator sunglasses on himself and me- we looked cooool. My cigar...

The Experiment

by mstrhole on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I'm a curious guy by nature. I like to find the answers to questions that start "what happens if I...?" And that is how I ended up downstairs in room one of the Family Sauna on my knees with my ass facing the wide open doorway, a pile of condoms and a bottle of lube next to my left knee, and a large pink butt plug sticking out of my ass. I'd posted the foll...

My Neighbor Fucks Me Ch. 02

by trevor6399 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

As Harold walked out of the room, I struggled to stand up and walk to his bed. My legs felt weak and with my hands in cuffs behind my back, I had trouble with my balance. I ended up knee-walking over to the edge of his bed where a minute ago I had been mercilessly face fucked and fed his cum. His order was ass up, face down and I leaned against the bed as I...

Deon Pt. 04

by Firsttimeforevery1 on Nov 2, 2020
Gay Male

As I was getting dressed for bed that night I noticed that two business cards had been put into my jacket pocket... At breakfast the next morning Jessica announced that they had been invited to stay over at a friend's house for New Years and as the house was closer to college and Deon's they would stay there for a few days before heading to Deon's and then...

My Downfall is Almost Complete

by NerdySex on Jan 23, 2018
Gay Male

My downfall is almost complete but I get ahead of myself. I had just graduated from high school and would start college in September. I worked at a summer job at a printing company. The other guys were all older, mostly late twenties and thirties. Bill took me under his wing and showed me the ropes. A few days later he invited me over to his place. We had a...

A Friendly Wager

by binroe on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I stared blankly at the television. It was a chip shot. A gimme. My favorite football team had just missed a 22 yard field goal that would of won the game. Hell my 14 year old neighbor could of made that kick. What rubbed salt into the mental wound was my girlfriend, who was dancing around the living room with glee. We had made a little wager on the game a...

The PA's Interview Pt. 02

by 1suitedbi on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

PART 2 - INDUCTION You look up at me and clear your throat, "Yes Sir, I would very much like to take up the position as your PA, Sir." "Very good Gary, now I suggest you go through to my washroom and tidy yourself up." You quickly rise from my desk retrieve your suit and head for the washroom. I am on the phone when you return, I gesture you to take a sea...

Used For a Week Pt. 04

by mralx99 on Aug 20, 2018
Gay Male

"Taken To the Limit " - Friday Part 1: https://www.literotica.com/s/used-for-a-week-pt-01 Part 2: https://www.literotica.com/s/used-for-a-week-pt-02 Part 3: https://www.literotica.com/s/used-for-a-week-pt-03 Things we do in the heat of the night can look insane in the daylight of the next morning. Waking up Friday I recalled the events since William cam...