Gay Buttplug Stories

92 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Money on the Side Ch. 01

by drew13579 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Part One, the interview… $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ College Guys Open Minded Love To Party $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ Ok, from the ad, I pretty much knew this wasn't going to be a job delivering pizza, but after two years of doing minimum wage jobs, I was on the verge of having to drop out of college for lack of money. And to be fair, I thought, I'd...

The New Order Pt. 03

by Iamkrazy4 on Dec 16, 2019
Gay Male

Part 3: My ass, my mouth, my job No, the guidance counselor didn't fuck me. Though, I would have let him. But, that says more about me than it does about him. What he did do was praise my on stage performance and say I the most enthusiastic "volunteer" so far. He complimented my dick taking abilities and described how my life would be from there on out. Th...

My Neighbor's Secret Ch. 05

by Caliber345 on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

One night a few days later, Will called me up. He invited a few buddies from the neighborhood over for Poker. Being a Texas Hold'em fan, I agreed to bring the beer and the chipset I have. An hour later, Will, five other guys, and I sat at the Poker table in his basement. Before I knew it, I was pleasantly buzzed and on tilt with my chips. "Don't worry, man,...

Turning Myself Gay Pt. 03

by bart_allen on May 29, 2018
Gay Male

To my mutual humiliation and arousal, the next morning at work, Marie could instantly tell. Truth was, I could see why: Nathan had fucked me three god damn times, and I my ass was sore as hell. Sure, he'd been tender as well at times, but one look at me and she knew. She just rolled her eyes at me, causing me to blush. She wanted to know what he looked like,...

House Boy Loses Control

by Twinklystarr on May 6, 2019
Gay Male

Casey had played with his ass lots of times. He loved waking up and sliding his finger in and out. Teasing himself. Even just rubbing his hole made his cock stick straight up. But Casey hadn't never taken a real cock before. He had played with a hairbrush and a sharpie. He even had a dildo under his bed at home. But Daddy's cock was completely different. W...

Jake and Danny Ch. 03

by funandbold on Jan 7, 2019
Gay Male

Danny was now mine! I had marked him with my cum, deep inside of his hole, now to certainly be my pussy! My DNA, my man juice, my life force, my boys, my swimmers were now doing their job, they were working frantically to find their way into his hot body, where they would meld with him and become a part of him forever! I knew that this was a really delicate...

Aquata Cove Ch. 61

by Feare909 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Aquata Cove Chapter 61: Pending Precipice "If we go through the Tower Trenches quick enough," Samudra said as he, Vanora, Ebba, and the Adras plot their next route, "We could make it to the Caspian Seas in time for the dancing jellies..." "No, we cannot go to the Towers." Vanora said. "Why not?" "We tried that once, remember?" Vanora said, "When we rea...

Losing My Anal Cherry

by pescaderoblue on Sep 15, 2017
Gay Male

Mike and I had a very special relationship. In our senior year in highschool he and his then-girlfriend had invited me to a threesome which had developed into a more or less regular fucking session. After that relationship had been over Mike and I, ever horny, but without any female partners to blow off some steam, had taken to whacking off together to the...

My New Daddy Ch. 03

by sissytoy20 on Mar 6, 2018
Gay Male

The buttplug that Sam had unceremoniously forced inside my tight asscunt had hurt like hell, but I'd enjoyed the feeling of being forced open with no warning. The little, pink butt plug wasn't very large, but it had felt like a giant donkey dick in my ass. It had flashed by in Sam's hand so quickly, maybe it was larger than I thought. It felt huge in my butt...

Surprise at the Door

by Luckystiff2112 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This just happened to me today! But it all started last night. My buddy came over and we sat around shooting the breeze; took a ride in his hotrod- a '69 RoadRunner! Way cool! We came back and proceeded to get pretty drunk. So I fed him, gave him some water to sober him up some, and then he left. I was home alone now. My wife is away for the weekend, and wh...