Gay Caught Cheating Stories

10,454 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

When Love Takes Over Ch. 07

by fuzzyNOLA on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

I never did have great gaydar, so it wasn't a big surprise I hadn't pegged Chance as playing for our team. But I can honestly say I have never been happier to discover another guy is gay. And I did spend a couple of happy moments imaging making out with Chance on a warm summer night in a truck parked in the back of a field (the preferred place for hooking up...

Learning to Score

by caughtsinning on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Edited by: MizTake - Thanks for all your help! ***** This was our second loss in row and the coach was pissed. He yelled at the entire team but the captain and I were the only ones he told to stay behind while everyone else went in the showers. "What's with you, Jackson??" The coach yelled at me. He could at least use my first name, Sam, like a normal pe...

Tad Ch. 03

by DrakeManley69 on Jan 21, 2019
Gay Male

Daniels address was easy to find but the gates that guarded the drive were shut, I parked right in front of them and was just wondering if I should text Daniel to let him know I was there when they began to open. I made my way along the drive which meandered through a small, winding avenue of trees before opening out into a larger clear area. There was a pic...

Can't Let Go

by LoveIsUniversal on Mar 12, 2019
Gay Male

Something didn't feel right ever since he started his basketball practice. Eli should have kept his eye on the ball, but he didn't. On a few occasions, he didn't even pay attention to what transpired on the court. He would look at his own coach for several seconds. Eli didn't say anything, and he didn't give any signals. He just kept his gaze on thirty-seven...

Straight Jock's College Boyfriend

by S_Queen on Oct 8, 2018
Gay Male

I peeked through the crack in the door. Chris was standing up. His pants were down by his ankles but he was still wearing his shirt, shoes and cap. In front of him, on his knees, was Jo. Jo was fully clothed. His head was moving back and forward slowly. Chris had his eyes closed, his hands on Jo's head. He was gently thrusting his cock in and out of Jo's mou...

A Riding Reunion

by KeithD on Aug 21, 2018
Gay Male

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of incest or incest content. ***** "When the Ecuadoran minister of tourism interviewed me, he said that no one ever gets attacked by a shark in the Galapagos Islands. He asked me if it couldn't have been a giant turtle. And I told him I knew a fuckin' turtle from a shark. He wasn't pleased with my attitude, but the...

Becoming His Prison Bitch Pt. 04

by LittleKay on Dec 12, 2018
Gay Male

Love love love feedback, leave comments, leave your love, leave suggestions, leave constructive criticism. Anything unnecessary, nit-picky or rude will be deleted however. ***** Darian looked down at Lexus as he slept and sighed. He probably should have told him. Well, he didn't exactly hide it but... He left the cell when he saw the crowds start to disp...

Jamie - The Journey Begins Ch. 21 - Bon Voyage and Welcome Home...

by Hutchison12 on Feb 12, 2019
Gay Male

We went back inside '58 Tour Eiffel,' enjoying some of the best food I've ever eaten, plus the view - wow it was just to die for - atop of Paris, looking down on one of the most beautiful cities below. My eyes and senses were in overload - the place, the people the ... feeling it gave me...that feeling that life is truly wonderful as it is... Right! No wonde...

Avery's Desire Pt. 19

by Chancem77 on Dec 11, 2018
Gay Male

Boomer stepped up onto the stage and tapped the microphone. "Hello? I'm very sorry for the delay but as you can see our lead singer, Avery, has taken ill. It will be just a moment while we figure out what's up and then I promise you, there will be live music tonight. Just bear with me a moment and the band will be back." He stepped back from the microphone,...

I Just Needed a Tune-Up

by rae121452 on Apr 3, 2019
Gay Male

I wouldn't exactly call Hamilton, Ohio the armpit of the country. Not exactly. I'd probably call it the dirty, infected ass hole of the country. And, I'd be allowed to because that's where I'm from. Hamilton is between Cincinnati and Dayton, close enough to both that neither one will claim it. Locally, it's known as "Hamiltucky" because it is supposedly eve...