Gay Choose Your Own Stories

21,362 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Jeff Comes Out for Baseball Ch. 2

by Bright Angel on Aug 22, 2017
Gay Male

“I think I can fit it in. There’s just enough room,” I said. “Alex, I can’t believe you want to put that thing in there. It’s way too big, and I know I’m gonna be sorry if you do,“ Jeff said. “C’mon. It’ll be fun. Let me put it in, you’ll enjoy it. I PROMISE!” I said. “I did it with my brother, and he not only enjoyed it when I did, now he does it with fri...

Ben Loves a Challenge Ch. 06

by PDreadful on Dec 2, 2019
Gay Male

They couldn't decide on a movie, so they ended up watching Firefly, which Ben was actually pretty pumped about. Watching Firefly with Dean seemed like a perfect date night. He'd catch Dean watching him every now and again and it made him smile. Eventually he lay down, putting his head in Dean's lap. It startled his lover, but Dean soon settled into it, and...

Gentlemen's Club Ch. 12

by Ywashere on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Sorry for the wait (don't you hate it when real life gets in the way) - here's a little something while I polish off the next character story. Y All characters are 18 or older. SHOWTIME The curtains pulled back to reveal a tall, muscular, blond young man on a haystack (the haystack was actually foam rubber covered with a hay-patterned cloth, but no one...

My First Cop

by nickshy on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This happened in the early '90s. One Saturday night, I went to a bar near a police precinct in the Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn. The bar is closed now. It was called Kelly's. I had just turned 18 and had to use fake ID to drink. I was a typical Brooklyn kid but still wet behind the ears. Guys had started to come on to me, but I was still struggling with my...

Fun and Games Ch. 04

by jm02201960 on Sep 15, 2017
Gay Male

We both got dressed and went out into the living room and he put on a movie called Trainspotting which is actually a cool flick. I relaxed on one of the chairs and we both started to watch it. About halfway through the movie, he just blurted out, "So do you want to fuck each other in the ass tonight or are we done?" I scooted my ass around on the chair as i...

Shameless [Nathan Lloyd]

by JasonClearwater on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

This story/book was originally published on Literotica as 'House of Persuasion' under the non-consent category, and contains strong elements of non-con/dub-con, and a supernatural theme. However, as it's one man's journey from straight to bi, I believe it fits this category better. It's quite dark. The story: Nathan Lloyd is a manipulative pretty boy who...

Cum Lover and Steve Pt. 10

by cumlover969 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I was sitting on my patio with my cock hard as a rock in anticipation of what was to come. Alan and Mike turned up right at eight as agreed. They wanted to tell me what took place on Sunday evening after we met. Mike, "We were so excited that we couldn't wait to do each other. We got on our bed and assumed a sixty nine position and began crazily gobbling ou...

The Therapist

by justawritertoo on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

It was Friday night and the phone rang. I picked it up and was surprised to hear that it was my wife's therapist. I knew about him, of course, but had never met or even spoken to him. He knew Sue was out of town for the week, so I was really caught off guard, and immediately worried by his call. "Ken? This is John Everett. I think Sue has told you about me?...

U-N-I Ch. 21

by unilive on Aug 6, 2018
Gay Male

I woke up on my left side, my eyes not quite willing to open. I slowly rolled onto my back and realised Rob wasn't in bed anymore. I tried to concentrate to see if I could hear any sound coming from the living room but there was none, everything was completely quiet and dark. It was still the middle of the night. For a few minutes, I tried to go back to slee...

Caught Fantasizing at Home Ch. 05

by NathanButler on Sep 18, 2017
Gay Male

Tommy pulled up his pants and tucked in his cock. He looked at me , shook his head and looked at Jake. "Where'd you find this one, man", nodding at me. "Fucking incredible. A natural. Best blowjob I ever had man. Seriously." Tommy spoke to Jake as if I wasn't there or as if Jake had let him borrow a nice car or some other object. Tommy looked at me, scof...