Gay Conservative Stories

458 results
Orientation
Length
Category
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com
Create your own smut fantasy with AI

Experimenting in College

by anotherfred on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

After growing up in a relatively conservative community, it was no surprise, looking back, that I was a little sexually repressed. Despite thinking about sex and jacking off all the time, I had relatively few opportunities to talk about sex with friends, let alone mess around! This was just before the Internet exploded (what I wouldn't have given to have ha...

Sonia's Birthday Surprise for Gavin

by nowiamhere on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

In my life I have always been pretty conservative. I don’t stand out in a crowd and I don’t take risks. Your typical nice average guy – that’s me. At 31, I have done ok for myself. The only major thing missing from my life was a family. But I knew one day I would meet the girl of my dreams and that part of my life would also fall into place. At least so I th...

Blackmailed into Sexual Slavery

by boyganymede on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Oakdale is the sort of socially conservative exurb where people go to raise their children in a "wholesome" atmosphere away from the city. Social life revolves around the town's four evangelical Protestant churches, and involvement in one of those churches is a must for business contacts. Guys like me who love cock have to be extremely discreet. On one day...

Taken by a Young Stud

by Davidb836 on Jan 20, 2020
Gay Male

I was raised in a very conservative area. If I was ever curious about being with another man before the age of 40 I don't remember it. It was taboo. The behavior was unwelcome in my friend group growing up. I can't tell you where that mindset began to change. The walls probably began to come down in my late 30s. Like many men I enjoyed watching porn from t...

Gaining Experience

by woman_inside on Jan 16, 2019
Gay Male

I was seemingly an ordinary Mexican guy walking down the street in a conservative Mexican town in the early evening. The street, a narrow street near downtown, was nearly deserted, and nothing indicated I was at the right place other than a tiny rainbow flag at the door. I rang the doorbell - the door unlocked almost immediately and I quickly stepped in, awa...

Raj Gets Ravished

by rajbabar886 on Sep 23, 2019
Gay Male

My name is Raj. I was born in the US into a conservative Indian family. By the time I turned 18 in August of 2004, I had not yet had any sort of sexual experiences. I did find that quite a few girls had taken a liking to me, especially Indian girls, but the fear of getting kicked out of my house pretty much forced me to focus on school and keep away. I wasn'...

Going in Slowly Pt. 01

by zephyer on Dec 24, 2019
Gay Male

Fiction I was raised in a town that was still pretty conservative in the 60 and 70s when a lot of the country was changing. The folks dragged me to church at every opportunity so we could be told everything was sinful, especially sex. School gave us the basic biology functions without details. Sex was rarely spoken of by adults around kids and teenagers an...

Public Wi-Fi

by justawritertoo on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Today's technology can make one a little paranoid. I'm well known in my rather conservative community and the last thing I would need would be for people to find out about my fantasies. Like many people, I have a phone, a tablet, a laptop, etc. and I connect to my work network from home frequently. Lately, I'd become somewhat obsessed about my internet trail...

No Wonder He's So Cocky

by dixeenormous on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

As a college freshman at a state school in the Rocky Mountains, I was a pretty conservative guy, especially considering all the boozing, drugs, and wild sex that was running rampant in my coed dorm. My high school years were very low key; I had dated the same girl since sophomore year, swam competitively, and studied hard. At university, I was in way over my...

Cam Slave to Real Slave Ch. 01

by ak_btm on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Prologue Ryan had always hidden that he was gay. He had grown up in a conservative town and had played football all of high school. An Asian boy, standing 5'10'' and weighing 175 lbs., he was lean and in pretty good shape. His bubble but was evident. His small 3-inch penis was often teased in the locker room, but he had learned to accept it and laugh with o...