Gay Costume Party Stories

4,324 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Historic Costumes

by MSTarot on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The phone has been ringing off the hook for the last week. "Historic costumes," I paused and waited for the inevitable question given it was October. "Yes, ma'am, we do rent for Halloween. No, we only carry costumes from pre-nineteen hundred." I rolled my eyes at the Hanna Montana as a slut request. "Yes, we have several pirate costumes in stock." Holding...

A Change in College

by WendyGear on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

I had just started college in a new town and was looking to start a new life. I am guy that is only 5'3 weighing in at 109lbs and have long brown hair that reaches the middle of my back. I had spent most of my teens as an outcast and was always teased for being small and looking like a girl. I was looking to living on my own and to be known as myself. I was...

Halloween Revisited

by sack on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

David felt a heaviness in the air as he hurried toward the hidden wine cellar. The sky had turned inky black and a few stray raindrops stung his face in the overcast gloom. It was Halloween, and night was swiftly falling. David had taken his strongest flashlight, complete with new batteries to cut through even the pitch black hiding place he had recently dis...

Spiking the Eggnog

by ladynina23 on Apr 1, 2020
Gay Male

*All characters are above the age of 18 "Shhhh! You're family is going to hear us!" I shushed my boyfriend before going back down to swallow his cock to the root again. We were at his Mom's house for her yearly Christmas Dinner. About two hours had gone by when Ryan snuck up behind me. After five cups of eggnog, Ryan cornered me under the mistletoe and sai...

Earning Danny Ch. 07

by EricMorrison on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Hey guys! Sorry I've been absent for such a long time, but I was busy. First it was the end of the semester, then the holidays, then the beginning of the semester, and well, you get the picture, it's a vicious cycle. Anyway, I'd thought of just giving up on the story altogether, since I never have the time to write, but so many of you have commented and e-ma...

Midnight Masquerade

by Xathandra on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Getting out of his car, Mark turned to look at his sister, Katie, shaking his head. Once more she had talked him into another crazy idea and he couldn't quite figure out how she'd done it. Ever since they had been young children, his twin had the uncanny ability to bat her eyes at him and get him to do her biding. He contemplated getting back into his car an...

Last Months in the City Ch. 04

by thealphamale on May 11, 2020
Gay Male

Chapter 4: The strange case of Danny Phantom and Marty McFly Jamie woke up first, immediately feeling the warmth of Chris' heat all over his body. He eased into the muscled frame that proved to be soft enough for him to feel comfort as he listened along to the quiet little breaths the boy let out- the same ones that lured him to sleep the night before. All...

Blood and Love Ch. 10

by Eternalivan on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter 10 ************** Sean's Story VI -- Halloween ******************************** "I am a vampire!" I growled at the mirror and started laughing. The costume looked perfect. I had spiked my jet black hair, paled my complexion and darkened my eye lashes and brows. Fake blood was dripping from the corners of my mouth while the fangs added authentic...

Samhain Chanted Evening

by Keith Mystery on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

"There was a time when you believed in Magic," Lenore said quietly, all the while staring at me with those weird, gold cat's eyes of hers. "Believed in the land of the Summer people." I hated it when she sprang that old soul shit on me. Not only was it creepy as hell, but the last thing I needed was to have to worry about past lives. I was having a bitch o...

Easy Access

by Apolo1 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

To say that I was in heat by the time my boyfriend Benny and I headed out for a Halloween party is an understatement, to say the least. What's worse, he knew that I was hornier than a proverbial toad, but for reasons that would only later become clear to me, he decided to make me hold off on getting some nookie. The aforementioned party was an annual shindi...