Gay Craigslist Stories

396 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Finally Did It...

by kilosierra80 on Aug 22, 2017
Gay Male

This is a totally true story. My first time was about 6 months ago. I was out of town on a business trip, and was just getting out of a marriage. I had always fantasized about sucking a cock, and had looked at Craigslist and jacked off thinking about it. While I was away, I got drunk one night and passed out in my hotel room. When I woke up, I was horny as...

Rally Party

by gary_4_u on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This story is a fantasy of what I would like to happen sometime. I hope you enjoy it. It's Saturday afternoon, August 6, 2011. I am in the Mangy Moose Salloon in Hill City, SD enjoying a cold beer after having ridden the 150 miles from my home in WY for the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally. I was waiting for some guys to show up that I had been messaging on Crai...

Blowjob in the Coffee Shop Bathroom

by Closetfaggotnyc on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I answered his ad on Craigslist. It was titled "black male looking for blowjob". There were pictures of him from the neck down showing his perfect, dark skinned, heavily muscled and tattooed body and his glorious, seemingly 10 inch, very thick cut black cock. I knew I had to have it. I emailed him saying I was a white faggot bottom and I'd do anything for...

Young/Old Hotel Room Fun

by xxox69 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This is a true account of how I lost my anal virginity. It was one of my first gay experiences, and it happened just after I'd turned 18. More of my sexual adventures will be uploaded if this one is well recieved. A few weeks after my first gay experience, with a guy my own age, I was horny and wanted more. Since I've always found older men to be a huge tu...

Learning to Deepthroat

by teachMeCock on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I have used craigslist to find guys that I can suck off. I think I have sucked cock for about 30 guys. I state in my ad that I want to swallow their load. Most shoot their cum into my mouth while I suck them. I swallow their cum and keep sucking their hard cock. Sometimes a guy will pull his cock out of my mouth and shoot his load on my face. Then he uses hi...

My Second Cock

by NJFUNGUY42 on Aug 24, 2020
Gay Male

This is a true story and part of my journey being bisexual. This is the second experience I had and will post more later. It was a month since I sucked my first cock and although it was not the best experience, I was not discouraged to do it again. I figured this time I would go for something local and with no expectations. I saw an ad in Craigslist for a...

A CraigsList Encounter

by Jaredh on Oct 15, 2017
Gay Male

It had been a while since I had ventured onto CL, and just as long since I had been laid. It had been close to a year. I finally worked up the courage to post an ad on CL again looking for local tops. The responses were coming in regularly and I weeded through them accordingly. As I went through my messages I began looking only at the ones with pictures at...

How It All Began

by youngindiantwink on Mar 25, 2019
Gay Male

Before I begin my story, I would like to introduce myself. I'm a 20 years old. Discovered that I'm bisexual when I was 18. I have a very slim figure, 5 feet 7 inches in height, 45 kgs and light skinned. I'm from India (Delhi). This is my first story here. So my story begins when I was 18. I was into blowjobs. Loved watching porn where the guy used to cum on...

Anonymous Hotel Facefuck

by DWMDenver on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

It was 2 o'clock Sunday morning. I leaned against the Silver Bullet (the old Chevy Cavalier that I inherited from my grandmother) puking up cheeseburger, Rolling Rock, and the cum of the anonymous financial advisor from Phoenix I'd just blown at the Cherry Creek Marriott. All I had wanted when I came home sweaty and horny from the gym, was a quick hookup to...

My First Time Sucking a Cock

by married_but_curious on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

A personal ad I ran on Craigslist: Are you married or str8 & curious about letting a man suck your cock? - 49 I'm married, but I was curious about what it would be like to suck a cock. So I placed a CL ad. After screening through all the replies and exchanging some pics and very hot and naughty emails, I met this married man at his house while his wife was...