Gay Craigslist Stories

396 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

CraigList Bill

by Triplebottom on Aug 29, 2017
Gay Male

I was so nervous. What the hell was I doing? No, I have to do this. I'm going to finally go through with it. It's been months since she's let me touch her. This is her fault. She drove me to do desperate things. I had to look elsewhere for affection. As I drove in the night, I told myself that I wasn't going to flake out. Not again. I flaked on a couple gu...

2nd Time Bi

by Glenn4bj on Oct 29, 2018
Gay Male

After giving my 1st blowjob, it was like my life opened up to endless possibilities. The problem was the whole small town thing. But I started checking guys' packages as much as women's asses and boobs. I still didn't want to make out with guys, like I did with girls, but I dwelled a lot on the idea of finding my next cock to suck. I'd wonder if a guy had a...

Story of a Bi Married Man

by StevenBiMWM on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I started hooking up with guys 10 years ago when I discovered Craigslist. My interest in gay sex started when I was a teenager and checked out from the library what I thought was just a science fiction book, The Man Who Folded Himself. The book's character travels back in time, meets an alternate version of himself, and they have sex. I was immediately arous...

Rape Fantasy

by MrJimJim on Oct 3, 2018
Gay Male

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of non-consensual or reluctant sex. * Rape fantasy First off, let me just say this is a 100% true story. It has taken me almost 2 hours to write down because I keep stopping to jerk off when I remember the sexy parts of what happened to me. So I've had a rape fantasy for many years, but never found anyone willing...

Becoming a Slave Ch. 03

by tkyguyjin on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter 3 – Five Fantasies Fulfilled 1 A couple of weeks had passed since I had accepted my sexuality. I truly loved cock, and Matt's cock in particular. I wanted to spend my free time with it in my mouth, or hand, or slapping my face, ready to taste and eat its creamy cum. Sadly, Matt was out of town quite a bit, although he did have me over a few more ti...

Post Craigslist

by loneguy01 on Jun 26, 2018
Gay Male

I am a mature, divorced bisexual man. I date women and enjoy sex with them but I really crave sex with men. I just do not have any romantic feelings towards men as I do towards women. Consequently, I keep my encounters with men discreet and secret. My main forum for hooking up with men had been craigslist. However, bowing to government pressure, craigslist d...

Rye's Encounters Pt. 01

by sissyrye on Dec 23, 2019
Gay Male

Note to reader: The following series of encounters are 100% non-fiction, best of my ability accounts of my real life encounters with horny men. Names, locations, and revealing details were altered to protect identities of course. PREFACE: Hi. My name is Rye. I am a cute, 5'9", blonde, big booty, white boy...with a hunger. I have a fairly symmetrical face...

Personal Ad Leads To My First BDSM

by BallwinMWM on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

True story First off, I would like to say that I have never written any erotic stories before. This story is true, and hopefully it will be the first installment in a multipart series of my adventures as a BDSM submissive. I am a 50 year old married white male. I am new to bi and new to being submissive. I did have a friend in high school (which was a long...

First Time with a Guy: A True Story

by princecharming420 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The following is a true story from my personal life. Some identifying details are omitted. I am writing this so I can relive the awesome memory and not forget. Hope you enjoy. ....................... I first began to appreciate the male form when I was a teenager. Before that I was only turned on by women, and I still am. But I have always been a bit of a...

The Oreo

by Tqtman on Mar 28, 2018
Gay Male

This is a true story about something that happened to me recently. When I'm bored and horny, which is quite often, I browse the local Craigslist casual encounters section. This is usually a waste of time because the ads are mostly repeats by the same people who are either obviously fake, unattractive, or not looking for what I'm looking for. And when you d...