Gay Cream Pie Stories

3,667 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

DJ Pt. 15

by o2byoung on Feb 6, 2018
Gay Male

Coming in Part 15 Clearing up the snow DJ and Jamie get a real surprise for Christmas Christmas Day, DJ plays with little kids (Jamie's cousins) Matt discovers his new voice Gloria gets her ring adjusted DJ gets a promotion Lots of emotions in this one folks. DJ Part 15 Merry Christmas Everybody! It's Christmas Day, at 6:00 AM and the alarm went off...

Trailhead Ch. 02

by KrisLace on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I'd been avoiding the trails in the afternoon for about a week now, not wanting to run into James but figured I couldn't let such things dictate my life. So there I was, cautiously scanning the parking area. I grabbed the dogs and made a beeline for one of the trails. The walk was overall uneventful though the dogs had a blast, and I found myself back at t...

Pizza Boy at the Door Ch. 17

by JKendallDane on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The final few days before the cruise was hectic. Too many of the little details that come with even a short, four day trip, had been put off until the last minute. But it all gelled together in time. Kyle had been on only two before; once as a high school graduation present that was four days to the Bahamas; and again when his parents had convinced him to...

The first time saying I love you

by summerlove91 on Apr 1, 2020
Gay Male

Dan and I had been seeing each other for a few months and during my second semester of my sophomore year in college, and I frequented him on Tuesday's at his apartment during my lunch breaks because that was the day I had a 3 hour break in my class schedule. On Tuesday's where I'd know I would see him, I would wake up extra early to get ready. I would even e...

Mr. Alexander's Bedroom

by rodneysteele41 on Aug 28, 2017
Gay Male

I couldn't remember how I got there. I couldn't remember a thing leading up to the moment I lowered my hips downward, and felt the thickness prying my asshole open wide and easing up into me. I had no idea how I had come to be dropping my ass down the long, thick length of my Algebra instructor's cock. My mind whirled and I could recognize my own moans, a m...

No Remedy for Love Ch. 04

by podga on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

A month had gone by since I'd been out to Garden City to pick up my stuff, and I still couldn't find a good excuse to contact Thomas. Maybe a not-so-good excuse would have worked equally well, just as it had last time, but somehow I doubted it. We needed a chance to spend some time together in a neutral environment, and I just couldn't figure out how to set...

Memories of a Lustful Youth

by Giganet on Nov 27, 2017
Gay Male

Just a summary of a few fond memories of my sexual "exploits"....others may follow in a later missive. I remember the first time a man made me cum. Paul was 25 years older than me (I was 20 or 22 at the time), and had been a long time friend and drinking companion. I knew he was gay, and I knew I had always been bi-curious, but I had only ever been with wom...

Nympho Coed Cum Feeding

by Alluring_Crimson_Shifter on Jan 16, 2019
Gay Male

Susan was friends with her co-ed neighbors Cameron and Jamal. They both had a beautiful complexion of mixed race, but seemed to be mostly white. Neither one of them was gay or bisexual. Sometimes when she thought of them it made her pussy wet. But truthfully her pussy was always wet. Right now she was so horny she would just about fuck anything. She walked...

Confessions of a Married Guy Pt. 04

by StephanieSeymour93 on May 11, 2020
Gay Male

My wife left town for five nights in spring a couple years ago. This was back when I was trying to be a good boy, staying sober, going to 12-step meetings and at least making an effort to quit porn. But I threw it all out the window when she left town. My binge started when I came home to an empty house on Friday night. Adrenaline surged through my veins wh...

Drunken Thrills

by AmethystMare on Jul 15, 2020
Gay Male

Donnie groaned, the world spinning and turning about him as he moved (at least, he thought he was moving) through the home of someone he didn't know. He couldn't have said where he was right there and then, off in a city that was not his home, although the penthouse suite was expansive and large, dripping with the tellings of wealth. He blinked, leaning aga...