Gay Cream Pie Stories

3,667 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

The Lake House

by Connermt on Sep 14, 2020
Gay Male

After twelve years, I found out my (now ex) boyfriend had been cheating on me for months. This meant I had to start a new life. Through our individual attorneys we hashed out a plan: he would stay in the house, I would take the lake house and enough cash from our savings (most of which came from renting said lake house) and a year's worth income and start my...

Maverick Cattle Company Ch. 05

by reddirtwriter on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

There are scenes of unprotected sex depicted in his story. In all cases it was between the two main characters, who are in a committed, monogamous relationship and were tested. If you aren't in the same kind of relationship, then you should always protect yourself and wear a condom. Darrin glanced at the blond young man he was helping with yet another ho...

Writer's Block

by ThoughtlessAngel on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I sat at my computer, the little indicator of where I can start writing blinking at me constantly while I mindlessly thought of what to write. A friend of mine showed me a website called "Literaunchy," where strangers share sexual stories, fact or fiction so that other strangers can get off of it. Ingenious, I thought but it occurred to me that writing somet...

Curiosity

by Diabloirishman on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

This began simple enough but turned into a total fucked up mess with me in the middle and center of attention. Having been married a long time it's easy to become very definitive in your lifestyle. For years my wife would always bug me about tasting my own cum or dining on a cream pie. Weather she blew me and fed it to me or eat her out after I came in her p...

Dumb Jocks Ch. 02

by dumbjocks on Jul 13, 2020
Gay Male

Leaving Rocky's room, despite every part of me wanting to fuck his ass again, I stumbled home as if in a dream. The excitement of finally fucking his big ass was coursing through me and, though my body and cock needed sleep, my mind couldn't switch off. He actually came while getting fucked, even with my limited experience with men, I knew that was rare for...

Mel Takes My Manhood Pt. 05

by RSchwuler on Apr 13, 2020
Gay Male

Standard disclaimer: this story is a very over the top work of fantasy, and it contains extreme humiliation, blackmail, and unsafe, non-consensual sex practices. If that's not your thing, please don't read it. Otherwise, enjoy! - This strange new state of affairs continued. Everyday I would report to the gym, strip to my jockstrap, and Cliff, my self-appoi...

On the Run

by robcub32 on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

My name is Lucas. I'm 18, almost 19 years old. And I'm running away from home. I hadn't planned on coming out to my mom and step-dad. Unfortunately, Mom caught me going down on one of my buddies and freaked out. She told my step-dad and the two of them ganged up on me. But as Emmett sat back while my mom told me that I was disgusting and that I was going to...

Jack and Toby Ch. 05

by kmillerk1 on Jul 31, 2018
Gay Male

**Toby** "Damn it son, pull your head out of your ass. You're twenty-six years old." My dad paced around my apartment yelling at me. "I'm not going to move on, Jack will be back. He always comes back." Defending Jack from my family is hard sometimes, but this time wasn't a possibility. "You hid the fact he has been fucking around on you again and then you...

Jim's Camping Trip

by yuyuassen on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Two months after his 18th Birthday, As Jim laid in bed, his leg were very tired. Jim had just finished his eagle scouts project, building a bridge in the creek. Sounds stupid right? But it worked, so now he was done with scouts forever! Wait, damn, he just said he would help his scoutmaster out with a camping trip! "Fuck, fuck fuck..." he thought as he undr...

On The Pill

by kicky1000 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Brock Barry Peterson was the handsomest man I had ever seen. He was over six feet tall and had smooth clear skin, blue blue eyes and white white wavy hair. He was always impeccably dressed in expensive well-tailored suits, crisp ironed shirts, and tastefully colored ties. He wore a special cologne. I don't know what it was, but it was heady. Sitting across f...