Gay Gay Boy Butt Plug Stories

22,838 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Swimsuit Shopping Pt. 02 - Cocktails

by Johnthong1989 on Sep 21, 2020
Gay Male

I woke up a little hazy. Unsure if last night really happened. I didn't believe it until I felt how sore my jaw was. My mouth had never been put through anything like that before. The night was confirmed again once I saw the anal lube, butt plug and skimpy black thong sitting on the table. I read the note again and tossed it in the bin, wondering who that gu...

Influencer to Sex Slave Ch. 06

by dreamymark9 on Dec 24, 2019
Gay Male

Author's note: This is erotic fantasy and completely fictional. The main character, Jack, is a fictional, generic social media star / influencer, and is not a real person. Apologizes I haven't written in a while, but thanks for the comments and messages. They really give me ideas and encourage me to keep going! ***** Jack reflects on how he went from being...

Dave and Scott Pt. 04

by willowview43 on Sep 14, 2020
Gay Male

Scott had rammed a huge butt plug in my ass while we watched my brother get fucked by his son, and told me to keep it inside me all night. He wanted my asscunt loose ready for a hard fucking the next morning. I went back to my bed but I didn't sleep much that night - the plug was so big I could feel it stretching my hole. A tight cockring was around my cock...

Ballet School Ch. 05

by BigWig69 on Jan 23, 2019
Gay Male

Chapter Five-Beck and Call Jim stopped by at his usual time and told me to follow him. I got to his room and went inside and on the bed were a series of butt plugs, small to really big. Here's what we're going to do Chris. Because I know you are horny for cock in your ass all day long, we're going to keep that beautiful ass filled up and pulsating with pl...

The Game Bus Ch. 04

by darkfaded on Mar 2, 2020
Gay Male

**Station 4: The Hot Seat** Adam walked down the dark and narrow pathway and arrived upon a metal door. He reached out for the metal handle on the door and opened it, revealing nothing but darkness inside. He stepped into the room apprehensively, and the door behind him automatically shuts itself, leaving Adam in pitch darkness. Adam stretched out his han...

The School's Fuck Toy

by Nasties on Sep 14, 2020
Gay Male

***This is 'one of them schools' where everyone is 18 years or older.*** I am an 18-year-old boy and I attend a catholic school. It is one of the best schools in the state. Most local political leaders, successful businessmen and other famous people actually attended this school. It is a well-funded school that does tend to focus the most on its sports faci...

How I Became A Cock Slave Ch. 03

by bearlover1689 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Back in my room I say perched on the edge of my chair, conflicted between wanting to keep the butt plug from moving in my ass and wishing that I could ride it like Mike's cock. I sat for nearly an three hours, typing on my computer and attempting to ignore my throbbing cock pressing against the fabric of the briefs Mike had given me, before my phone vibrated...

My Neighbor Made Me Do It Ch. 08

by CapnSteelBoy on Sep 28, 2020
Gay Male

My Neighbor Made Me Do It Ch. 8 by: CapnSteelBoy ...down, down, down the spiraling rabbit hole we go.... --------------------------------------------------- Chapter 8 bah bah bah bah! That damn alarm again! Untangling myself from my boyfriend's embrace, I moved my hand and smacked the alarm clock off. Heaving a heavy sigh, I got up from the bed, Jamie c...

Becoming a Gal Friday Pt. 09

by Showoff888 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Here I am standing naked in red 6 inch plastic high heel platform shoes, all dolled up in makeup with red lipstick and sporting a semi-erect cock being held in a fabric cock ring thong that is also holding a penis shaped butt plug in my ass. I am in my Ex's apartment complex in the morning hours with David in an elevator. I feel so vulnerable and so much l...

James Ch. 03: Surprise UPS Throat Fuck

by vanisland1983 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I would love to hear your input! Contact me through the contact tab on my profile. Chapter 3 of a young man being forced by a stalker. I would warn you about it, but then, that's why you came here to read it you naughty boy... ***** Things have been weird this week. A girl asked me out for a date but I declined. I'm not entirely sure why, she just didn...