Gay Gay Boy Butt Plug Stories

22,838 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Don't Look Back Ch. 28

by ShelleyRunyon on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

A few weeks had passed since their trip to San Antonio, and nothing had been said about the vibrating butt plug. Marshall began to wonder if Lee'd forgotten about it, and what he'd said he had in store for Marshall. But he sure as heck wasn't about to remind him. He knew better than that. When Lee was ready, he'd know it. So Marshall stopped thinking about i...

Taking the Neighbor Ch. 09

by jjdtx on Apr 30, 2018
Gay Male

Allen came downstairs from taking his shower, he was naked and reached for his shorts. "Wait," I said, "You won't be wearing those." I beckoned him over to me, I placed a cock ring around his cock and balls, snapped it into place. "I love these!" He said, as I stroked his hard cock. I then handed him a t-shirt, plain, black, with no logos or emblems. He...

Demands on Him Ch. 03

by latenightkiss on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I stared at my boss, dumbfounded by his presence on my doorstep. It had been more than a week since I'd seen him, and I certainly hadn't invited him to my house for tonight's party. The last thing I wanted was to ring in my New Year with the reason for all my hard-ons this week. "Gonna let me in, baby boy?" I stepped out onto the porch, closing the door be...

A Night Out and In!

by Wheelbearotx on Jan 7, 2019
Gay Male

I was just home from work and jumped in the shower. I was going to make a little dinner for myself once I rinsed off. Looking forward to a night of television and video games. I could entertain myself easily for the evening. Dad had a cocktail party for work later this evening, leaving me to my own devices... Or so I thought. I had just dried off when he wal...

The Boy At My Door... Ch. 03

by funguy2223 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

It's been ten days since this teen boy first knocked at my door. I remember when I first looked through the peephole to see proof that he was legal and had shaven his thin eighteen year old body for me. He was such an innocent boy in that first moment, so horny and so inexperienced. How was he to know that what I had been doing to him was anything other than...

The Beast Who Changed My Life Pt. 03

by anindianchub on Mar 28, 2018
Gay Male

After our first round of sex, we both hit the shower and soaped and cleaned each other off. He asked me to stay for the night and I was more than happy to do so. When we stepped out of the bathroom, he told me to follow him to the bedroom. His bedroom had a massive king size four-poster bed which he asked me to lie down on my back. When I did as he said, he...

A Load of Help Ch. 05

by Brass_ankle on May 1, 2018
Gay Male

"Ugh!" Connor said as he sat down at the pub. "What's up?" Tommy asked. "You act like you got something up your ass!" Connor blushed, he didn't want to say that he really did have a butt-plug stuck up his ass. Which at the moment was making him very uncomfortable. Despite the loud music, he knew that almost forty-minutes before, he almost got fucked in the...

My Neighbor, the Dominant Top

by dixeenormous on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

My downward spiral into a submissive bottom slut started late in life. I'm still very much in the closet and outwardly I appear as the perfect suburban husband, father, employee and neighbor. I love my wife and family but I recently found a new hobby that I crave with a passion; I can't get enough of my neighbor's big hard cock. It all started innocently en...

Family Traditions

by chocolatebook on Jun 18, 2019
Gay Male

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of incest or incest content. ***** "Where are we going, Uncle Greg?" I asked curiously. We had been in the car for nearly an hour. My dad, uncle and I had been planning this trip for months but they wouldn't tell me any details. All I knew was that it was an important family tradition. "We're nearly there, Ben," U...

House Boy - Casey's Wild Ride

by Twinklystarr on May 20, 2019
Gay Male

Daddy slowly unbound Casey's restraints, freeing the boy's hands and feet. Casey rubbed his hands over his chest, then began to lick his fingers, sucking the cum off each one. Daddy pointed the camera at him. The boy placed his feet on Daddy's chest and then carefully brought one foot down to Daddy's cock. He softly teased him, feeling Daddy's girth through...