Gay Gay Boy Butt Plug Stories

22,838 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Raffled Off

by Humilifuck on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I was barely out of my teens when I met "Big Jim." I was an innocent boy with a great ass, he was a leather top-man with an extra large cock. He introduced me to his collection of butt plugs and dildos of various shapes and sizes. He used them to stretch open my tight boy butt so he could fuck the hell out of me with his oversized cock. He also introduced me...

I Hate My Master Ch. 18

by maxpotter on Aug 26, 2019
Gay Male

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of non-consensual or reluctant sex. ***** Timmy fucked me twice, got blown, and had my tongue working on him the rest of the time. All while playing his game. I was worn out. He didn't care how tough this was on me, just that he was feeling good. I didn't know if it would ever end. He got a text, checked his phon...

Ben is Kept Under Control Ch. 02

by verdunsears on Mar 26, 2019
Gay Male

I'd spent a wonderful night of bondage, tit play, cock-sucking and piss play with a hot older man named Carlo, but had no way of getting in touch with him for a repeat session. Since arriving in Toronto a few months previously I'd mostly spent my nights with gay guys my own age, drinking and dancing at places that we jokingly called "S and M bars" (i.e. "St...

My First Big Black Cock

by babaca789 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This is my first submission, please let me know what you think! All comments are welcome :) ***** Well, I was about 18 years old and fresh out of high school. Horny as hell, constantly jerking my cock at porn, thinking about girls (I was actually pretty straight at this point) and trying to fuck as many girls as possible. I had hooked up with a few guys t...

The New Slave Ch. 03

by martin_x59 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I would like to start by saying I am new to writing so I hope you don't judge me too hard on my literary naivety. Nor am I experienced in Bondage or Master Slave relationships. This story is pure fantasy from my part and is about what I find erotic and stimulating. Please bear this in mind when reading the story. I hope you find it as stimulating reading as...

Rubber Puppy

by RbbrAndy on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

After a busy day at work I eventually left the office later than normal, I headed to the local train station to catch a train home. Things were clearly not going in my favour as I soon discovered that all trains had either been delayed or cancelled due to an earlier incident at another station nearby. I decided that instead of waiting for a train that I woul...

Straight to Bi, Cam to Real Life

by dlcalguy on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

After I finished university, I struggled for a good-paying job and money was tight. But I couldn't face living back at home. I managed to find a room to myself in a house-share with two other guys and three women. We were mostly in our early twenties and doing various entry-level jobs. One guy, Pete, was older. About 45. He was on a temporary assignment in o...

One Disgusting Pervert

by Formosa46 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

You seemed genuinely surprised when I reeled around and grabbed your wrists quickly pinning your hands above your head against the wall. With my face right in front of yours I looked you in the eyes and taunted "Dan I'm about to prove you are one disgusting pervert." We had been exchanging steamy texts for over a month. Sheepishly trying out new possibilit...

Outted by the Boss Ch. 02

by BmthAdmirer on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

After finding out Neil was not going to be into the office this morning was good for me as I was not quite ready for running into him as yet so I was glad to be working with Rich our part timer on the site although I always had the feeling that morning that Rich may have been told about what Neil saw online the night before and found myself asking questions...

My Downfall is Almost Complete

by NerdySex on Jan 23, 2018
Gay Male

My downfall is almost complete but I get ahead of myself. I had just graduated from high school and would start college in September. I worked at a summer job at a printing company. The other guys were all older, mostly late twenties and thirties. Bill took me under his wing and showed me the ropes. A few days later he invited me over to his place. We had a...