Gay Gay Buttplug Stories

22,838 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

The Stranger

by WatchingAndWaiting on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

!29f_UseMyBf - I want you to slap him around good. don't hold back. make him cry. and don't let him cum, okay? it's all selfish. all about you. okay? hungBristol24 - yea - where is he? does he have flatmates or anything? !29f_UseMyBf - He's staying alone. The address is no. XX Graining Pl, BSXX XXJD. Just knock loudly, and when he asks who it is, say you'r...

Highway Ride Ch. 02

by buttcheeks777 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This is a fantasy of mine; no more, no less. It's not real! Please don't leave negative feedback if you're surprised that it's male-on-male sex. ***** .. The van came to a stop and I was still tied to the ceiling. I was just hovering there above the carpeted floor of the van so that my ass was about 2 or 3 feet off the floor; perfect butt-fucking height. S...

I Used to be Straight Pt. 02

by FreakyBiFantasyGuy on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

No characters or events are real. All characters are 18+. ***** It was a week after that fateful day that Felix got his revenge for his brutal fucking. I arrived at his house after school as it was his birthday sleepover and I was invited. There were seven of us in total; myself, Felix, and five mutual friends, all of them gay. It was getting late when, h...

Dirty Fantasy Becomes Reality

by buttcheeks777 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

-This is a fantasy of a man (me) being forcefully taken by other men and contains some things that not all may want to read about, including spanking, anal sex, pissing, enemas, etc. If you're not into this type of fantasy please don't leave negative feedback. If this turns you on, please send me a message. It's written in a casual style, not a heavy, formal...

Enslaved by Myself Ch. 03

by Lausunaht on Sep 14, 2020
Gay Male

I was dreading what was about to happen. My master was going to hurt me badly to ensure I would never rebel. I knew this for certain because I would do exactly the same if the roles were reversed. I could only hope that my affection for myself was strong enough to limit the pain. He left me tied up alone for hours, I was thirsty as I didn't drink the whole n...

How I Found a Keyholder Ch. 02

by 1077ad on May 12, 2020
Gay Male

2.a: A verbal contract I had the best night's sleep I'd had in weeks, or maybe months. But it only took a few seconds after I woke up for the memories of the night before to come flooding back to me, and I nearly freaked out. Getting fucked by a stranger in the bathroom of a gay bar was one thing. But having to make that walk of shame, nude except for the...

The Hotel Room...

by funguy2223 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I have been thinking lately, and think I may have a good idea. I have a proposition for you. You should get on the web and find a bunch of dirty minded middle aged men that live in our general area. Tell them that you are having a 24 hour party and that you have a fully shaved, blindfolded, and handcuffed young guy that they can use any way they like and th...

Another Day Off Pt. 02

by OffNSFW on Jul 27, 2020
Gay Male

In the bedroom, in a reading chair, sits Mr. Rooney. On his knees in front of Mr. Rooney is Mr. Frye, his back to me. They're both nude. Mr. Frye is giving Mr. Rooney a blowjob. I'm starting to understand what Mr. Frye meant when he said he and Mr. Rooney socialized. Mr. Rooney leers at me over Mr. Frye's bobbing head, a smile curling up under that terribl...

Punished Asian Shoplifter Ch. 04

by asianspankee on Sep 15, 2017
Gay Male

A few days after my second punishment session, I decide to return to your store for some much-needed shopping. While I am inside I spot the two college-aged employees doing some stocking and price-tagging work. They must have recognized me because I see them whispering to each other and snickering while looking at my direction. I feel so embarrassed I quickl...

Converted to Gay

by bart_allen on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This story is partly inspired by messages from fans, with slight adjustments. Thank you for reading. ***** I wanted to share with you one of my current projects. A twenty five year old male by the name of Eric. Nothing too special in the looks department, but not too shabby either. He was neither heavy or slim, perhaps a slight softness to him. His eyes we...