Gay Gay Buttplug Stories

22,838 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Turning Myself Gay Pt. 03

by bart_allen on May 29, 2018
Gay Male

To my mutual humiliation and arousal, the next morning at work, Marie could instantly tell. Truth was, I could see why: Nathan had fucked me three god damn times, and I my ass was sore as hell. Sure, he'd been tender as well at times, but one look at me and she knew. She just rolled her eyes at me, causing me to blush. She wanted to know what he looked like,...

The Mirror to My Soul Ch. 03

by bjmichaels on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I stayed close to Richard's car the entire way to the hotel. I didn't want to risk displeasing him again. My bottom was a painful reminder of what happened when I made him angry. The room, or I should say suite, was huge and classy. It looked very expensive. Richard must be doing very well for himself, I thought. "Strip to your panties!" he suddenly ordere...

The Dairy: Spot and the New Calf

by thaidom30 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Has been edited by Nom de Plume for spelling and grammar. Thank you. ***** The sweet and savory smell of food cooking was all it took to wake up Spot. He stretched out in a big, full body stretch. Flexing his muscular hamstrings and massive shoulders. His brown chest hair covered most of his body like fur. Master made sure Spot kept his public parts clean,...

How I Found a Keyholder Ch. 03

by 1077ad on May 12, 2020
Gay Male

3.a: The treadmill Wednesday had come around again. I had gotten a message from Sir to be at his place for one p.m. and I was achingly horny. Besides the fact that I had been locked for a month now, far longer than I ever had been before, I was still feeling the residual excitement from shooting that video in the parking garage on the weekend. So, after doi...

Bootcamp Pt. 01: Initiation

by sexdonuts on Aug 8, 2018
Gay Male

I've always tried to look confident, self assured, masculine, and in charge but internally I've had a desire to submit for years. It all started when I was twenty, in college, and curious, and discovered kink. I remember finding a video of a man suspended by ropes and being tormented by a room of horny houseguests, and wishing I could be in his position. To...

1-2-3...My First DP

by lbtraveler on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Since being introduced to the pleasures of man on man sex I had begun to crave it even more. Luckily my new friends, Alex and Mitch, were always more than willing to accommodate my need for cock. It seemed like the more I was fucked, the more I wanted to be fucked. If I wasn't able to get together with them I was looking for other ways to get off with someth...

A Shave, A Cockring, A Thong

by tallsmooth on Mar 26, 2019
Gay Male

The cool onshore breeze from the lake tickled and cooled my bare ass cheeks, which were starting to show a shade of pink from their first exposure to the sun's rays, which I imagined reflecting off the blue glass knob of the metal butt plug I had inserted before lying down in the sand It was time to roll over, something I had been thinking about doing, but...

Naked Scott Ch. 05

by tattoo_dragon on May 12, 2020
Gay Male

Writer's note: this scenario contains extreme dominance and submission as well as master/slave role play. Just a heads up in case that is not your cup of tea. *** At eleven o'clock on Friday night, there was a knock at my door. My body jumped to attention. My cock started getting hard as I went to let him in. My hand was trembling slightly as I raised it...

(Un)Natural

by naradragonfly on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

I stare at the wall, listening to the beat of my heart count off seconds, concentrating on keeping my breath slow and steady. I'm not twelve anymore. I'm twenty-six. I'm a successful accountant. I shouldn't be this freaked out. I close my eyes again. Take a few deep breaths. Open them. The fresh paint of the wall stares back at me. Polished plastic tiles o...

Gay for a Day

by Compdood on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

"So, I want to try being gay for a day." "Sorry, what did you just say?" "I've been thinking and I've decided that I want to try being gay, just for a day." Dumbfounded, she looked over at her man. She wasn't sure what to say. Her mouth hung open, but no words came out. "I want you to arrange everything. I want you to arrange a gay makeover, so I look th...