Gay Huge Butt Plug Stories

13,470 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Bad Cards, Good Guys

by 69pat69 on Apr 3, 2019
Gay Male

Note: My previous submissions were in the third person, I really wanted to write as first person for this story. I really think it gives a different feel to the story. * It was the usual poker night, but not the usual location. Marie and I along with three other couples had decided to spend the long weekend more or less off the grid. The cabin we had rente...

Latter Day Sinners

by walterio on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Jack Jenson was in his office on a rainy Saturday morning looking at porn on his computer. He had been rained out his golf game and had decided to chill out with a cup of coffee and check the newly posted free porn. He liked watching European porn where beautiful babes with natural bodies did it all. He loved watching guys with big cocks like his stick them...

Tim and Al Ch. 01

by Harry_Ballsack on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This is the first in a series of stories about a bi-curious guy that decides to explore his fantasies with a Master he met online. * Well there he was, in the parking lot, with a bag full of the requested items. Could he do it? Could he knock on the door and really push the envelope of his experiences. He got out of the car and walked into the lobby and a...

My Shame

by justinsshame on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

We would often go to the gay club to hit on girls who were hiding from straight men, ironic I know. Well, in Salem, the bars didn't close until 2:30 am. My friends were bored of the speak easy, so they ended up leaving. I told them I would just take a cab home. The night was ending, and as always, people, me included, were looking for after parties. Two gu...

An English Boy Gets Turned Out Ch. 04

by RustyRover on Oct 13, 2017
Gay Male

I woke up late on Saturday morning and luxuriated in the knowledge I had no work for university or the book store for 2 whole days. As I was coming to, I felt a slight soreness in my ass and that reminded me I had to watch and study gay porn. Perhaps it wasn't going to be such a great weekend after all. I started to replay the events of last night and remem...

Straight Man Cums in Gay Massage

by Rosko Busby 2005 on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

Shane explodes in Special Gay Massage for Straights The five of us who ran the local gym were all gay and regular sex partners. We had shared many group sessions where we pretended to capture one of the group and subject him to fucking and torture. One of the fantasies we shared though was to do this for real and to force a good looking straight chap into j...

Me and My Boy Ch. 06

by willowview43 on Feb 12, 2019
Gay Male

Billy had hold of my hard cock up the leg of my shorts, slowly stroking it making it grow to its full size. "Are you still plugged?" I asked him. "Oh yeah and it's making my ass hungry for cock" he replied. I lifted up off the chair and Billy pulled my shorts down to my ankles. He started kissing and licking the head of my cock, running his tongue into the...

Slippery When Wet

by bearbottom505 on Sep 23, 2019
Gay Male

How did I end up like this? With a leather collar around my neck and a leash wrapped tightly around this alpha male fist. He was so big and strong. I could feel his hard body pressed against me, his hairy chest on my back. Most of all the feeling of his long thick hard cock sliding up and down my crack pressing against the large butt plug he had put in my as...

Anal Seduction Redux Ch. 02

by wiley4377 on Apr 24, 2018
Gay Male

It was Saturday on a warm spring morning when Wiley woke with a very hard erection. Just four months after losing his virginity to Bill's massive member in the adult bookstore peepshow. He awoke thinking about the day before when Bill fucked his horny ass. Bill was dependable every day whereas George was maybe twice a week. The previous episode was a great...

Jesse's Charming Plan

by JasonClearwater on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

* * * * * After Jesse catches his best mate, Will, fucking his girlfriend, Lucy, newly-bisexual Jesse devises a plan to teach Will a lesson. * * * * * This story follows on from: 1) The lad with the cock in his mouth (GM) 2) Jesse, it was really nothing (NC) I hadn't originally intended to write a series, so it's not labelled as one. There's a common ti...