Gay Identical Stories

623 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com

Brothers and Friends

by dondave on Sep 15, 2017
Gay Male

Having an identical twin means, among other things, always having a topic for conversation. If I'm talking to someone at a party, and the conversation starts to flag, all I have to do is mention my twin brother and off we go. People are fascinated; they want to know if we still dress alike (not any more, we're 35 now), if people still mistake us for one anot...

Truth Or Dare - The Other Guy

by RaulBloodworth on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Author's note: this is basically identical to the other story I wrote, Truth or Dare, except this is told from Andy's perspective. ---- Andy had the biggest boner of his life. He was sitting in the living room with his friends Matt, Kate, and Stacey, and he was watching Kate give Stacey oral sex. They'd all come round to Andy's place for a drinking sess...

Twin Twinks

by Boxlicker101 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Robert and Raymond Stewart are identical twin brothers, who were the pride of their parents when they were born but, early in their lives, they both became aware they are gay. Now 19 years old, they share an apartment, because those same prideful parents decided long ago the twins would not be welcome in the suburban family home any longer than they were leg...

My Brother and His Boyfriend

by londonganymede on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

* PART 1: NOAH * Even though Aaron and I were identical twins, our personalities couldn't have been more different. He was very outgoing, loved spending time with friends, and didn't mind being the center of attention. I hung out with him and our friends every now and then, but I preferred to keep a low profile and spend most of my time online. Even so, A...

Better Late Than Never

by bjmichaels on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

"Hey, cutie, same time next week!" Thomas said when he noticed I was awake. He was standing beside the bed wearing only his skimpy, string bikini briefs that were identical to my undies; the only difference being, unlike my briefs, his could barely contain his 'package.' "Why are you leaving so early?" I whined, rubbing the sleep from my eyes. "I have to...

A Summer of Firsts - Reimagined

by Turbidus on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I posted a different version of this story a few weeks ago. It had a very dark ending. If you've read that story you can skip to ALTERNATE ENDING, the first section is identical. I'm curious to see if the story is better accepted without the grim ending of the first version. Thanks yet again to LarryInSeattle for his editing assistance. Everyone depicte...

Adam and Kyle Ch. 03

by HVidese on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Hello once again! This is the third installment of the "Adam and Kyle" series. Also, the identical previous installments are titled under "Friends 'til the End", but will discontinued and simply be "Adam and Kyle". As always, feedback and comments are highly appreciated. I hope you enjoy! ------------------------------- Chapter 03 "You did WHAT with Miss...

Finding It with Tim Pt. 03

by alexcarr on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

I feel completely attached to Tim now. Mike his twin brother continue to share me and it feels so wonderful. Tim is disabled after a serious car crash and being almost identical brothers, Mike was caring enough to worry about Tim's sexual needs. And that is where I came in. We are all bisexual and can enjoy the best of both worlds. And yet, having said that...

Friend's Father Ch. 03

by EroticJoeRotica on Oct 31, 2018
Gay Male

I found myself staring at a complete stranger in the bathroom mirror across from me. Stunned face, cloth in hand, I saw the mess that was both identical to myself and unrecognizable at the same time. Some of Jack's cum was still present. Chin still wet with spit. "Let's see," I thought to myself. "In less than 24 hours I was not only seduced by my best fri...

Doing the Dirty Pt. 02

by Robert_Furlong on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

It's odd but strangely compelling to watch your own son masturbating right there in front of you. I was fascinated to see how different his technique was from my own - his hand seemed so much more frantic and his fingers more agile - while marvelling at so many physical similarities between us. His cock was ever so slightly bigger than mine, but other than...