Gay Missionary Stories

689 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Gym Daddy

by Daddysboi1234 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Hi, my name is Nick. I'm a gay 18 year old living in Milwaukee. I started going to the gym last summer just to get in shape-I had no idea that would be where I met my daddy. I was slightly muscular, with broad shoulders, petite pecs and sizeable biceps, complementing my 7-inch cut dick. I noticed daddy right away-he was in his mid-forties; his bulging bice...

Hotel 3-way

by Slimstud24 on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I'm a 24 year old single bi guy. 6 feet tall 160lbs in pretty good shape, 8 in cut dick. I enjoy women very much but also have an interest in messing around with a hot guy. I was at home alone one evening, surfing the internet, and decided to log onto the gay chat room. No sooner than I logged on I got a message. "Hey whats up?" "I'm good, you?" I replied...

Big Dick Gay Sex Ch. 02

by cut7nchlookn on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I had a second time to hook up with a hitchhiker I had picked up on a rainy cold night in Three Rivers, Michigan and dropped off in South Bend, Indiana. Tom gave me his phone number and told me the next time I got into the area to call him. A couple of months after our first encounter I decided to take him up on his offer. I had to stay in SB overnight on...

First Time Ever

by athletictwink on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I was 22 years old, slim and very athletic, have always had girlfriends and have always been very dominant with them. I grew up privately schooled and in the church, but still loved taking my girl whenever and wherever like a normal guy... Until I met a guy named G. I met him while bowling, an athletic looking 34 year old black guy, not sure why he suddenly...

How I Became Bisexual

by eagerbttm80 on Jun 24, 2019
Gay Male

I've been wanting to tell this story for a good while now, but never got around to it. I don't know how hot this is gonna be or whatever, but it sure was for me. This is a story about the very first time I was ever fucked by another man. To begin with, I was around 35 when this first happened. I've been with women my whole life, but the idea of being fucked...

Don’t Mess with a Missionary Man

by mrwankles on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I live in a community where too many guys spend their Sunday mornings attending Sunday School and their summer evenings at Vacation Bible School instead of going hiking, going water-skiiing, smoking pot by a pool, or grabbing a beer together after work. I tried to mind my own business but when people like me wouldn't come to them, they would instead come to...

Stallion Station Ch. 01

by sr71plt on Aug 28, 2017
Gay Male

The old dump of a motel that was here nine months ago has been transformed into something pretty nifty, the young carpenter, Constantine—known by everyone but his mother as Dino—thought as he left the movie studio he'd just put the finishing touches on and strode across the line of refurbished motel rooms toward the men's gym at the other end. The only probl...

Blowing Eric

by Waterstone on Oct 6, 2020
Gay Male

On a warm New York night in June 2017 I found myself looking for a horny stud on Craigslist's "Men Seeking Men" page. It was late at night, and I had a massive urge to suck cock. I am skilled at fellatio, but also very selective, so just any guy was not going to do. As I screened posts, one with the subject line of "Straight, horny & curious" caught my eye....

Met and Bred by my Biological Dad

by yeti8080k on Mar 31, 2020
Gay Male

Editor's note: this submission contains scenes of incest or incest content. * This is how I met my biological father. I was adopted as a baby. I didn't meet my bio-Dad until I was eighteen, since I was born in a place where records of the adoptees and their biological parents were sealed until we, the adoptees, become adults. I'm just going to call him Da...

Jim and Al: A Man's Tale Ch. 02

by archeopteryx_feather on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I stretched back on the bed, after showering still reeling a bit from one of the most intense orgasms of my life. Jim hadn't lifted his head since he laid back down. We smelled like soap the room smelled like sex. "Wassa matter, man? Getting old bro?" I teased. "I guess so. Or I'm just not used to cumming like that. I have never had my cock down anyone's t...