Gay Mistaken Identity Stories

1,075 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

A Story from My Youth Pt. 02

by SpeedoLee on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Since my last encounter with Pete we had crossed paths several more times though the end of my final year in High School. We'd been in Phys Ed sessions together and even on the same football team at the end of the summer. All the trouble between us had stopped and we spoke occasionally, albeit only briefly. I'd felt like he was more distant than I was, which...

Not So Boring Afternoon Ch. 02

by agpatch2 on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

So for a variety of reasons, I never made it back to the adult book store during that Spring Break. I did, however, have wonderful plans for my first day back at school. I purposely went back a day before my roommates so I could check out the campus glory holes. For about two months before that enlightening Spring Break, I had known about two separate bathro...

The Boyfriend Experience

by Frank8787 on Oct 12, 2020
Gay Male

Here's the first part of a story that should span multiple entries. It's partly based on my own experiences exploring my sexuality in college: John approached the home and sighed. It was a nice, spacious home in a fairly affluent area, and a home he'd visited many times before. He knew tonight would be difficult, however, and his stomach was in knots. John...

Heaven On Earth Ch. 03

by byIL85 on Aug 17, 2017
Gay Male

Heaven on Earth: Chapter 3 Cutting I don’t know how long I stayed up on the roof alone. It could have been a minute, it could have been an hour. In the back of my mind, I knew that Jane and I could never get married. This talk was inevitable, otherwise we were both going to spend the rest of lives wishing for something greater. But Jane said that I stared a...

Hard To Explain

by timmywells on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I feel like an idiot because that's what I must look like, dressed like a third rate private investigator with a rumpled raincoat and a beat up fedora pushed as far down on my head as possible sitting in a Starbucks. The disguise, which is pretty much all this garb is, was designed to conceal my real identity because I don't know what I would do if anybody e...

Once Was Lost Ch. 03

by taylorreed on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Just a quick note..I want to thank everyone for your generous comments. I am very thrilled that you guys seem to like my stories..so thank you! Blessings Taylor. PS If you leave a comment and you would like a reply, don't make it anonymous ok...I enjoy "talking" with you. Justin* * For the rest of the day Justin thought about Stephen and what he was g...

Second Time

by married_but_curious on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

It took a while before I decided I wanted to do anal again, but I ran a few ads, and finally found someone who talked me into meeting him who didn't sound crazy or whatnot, and turned me on with his emails, talking dirty about how he'd slowly seduce me and "make me his bitch". I'd arranged to meet him at a condo in Honolulu. I didn't have a picture, just a g...

Blood and Love Ch. 08

by Eternalivan on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Sean's Story V – The Funeral I *************************************** "May her soul and the souls of all the faithful departed through the mercy of God rest in peace." With the final words of the priest the coffin was buried and Tara Smith's burial ceremony concluded. Evan put an arm around my shoulder and hugged me tightly. Emily and her mother were inco...

Cock Lover: A Lifetime of Pleasure Ch. 02

by jsouth1974 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

My relationship with Kirk had been amazing. I craved every moment naked in his bed or taking him into mine. All summer I explored my new identity. I couldn't wait to leave work and run home. As soon as he walked in the door, I was on my knees. Every weekend I spent with him. He explored my body and I learned the many ways to please an older man. I learned th...

Gay Under The Table

by merichane on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I still remember the first time I replied to a gay personals ad online. I was only 18, in the first month of university in a new city away from everyone I had ever known. Hung looking for younger gay 37yo bwm, masculine, drug and disease free Looking for someone who likes kissing, sucking, maybe fucking. I sent him my stats and a face shot taking at an...