Gay Muscle Theft Stories

4,907 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Straight Tequila Pt. 03

by Ryan Carlyle on Mar 27, 2018
Gay Male

Author's Note -- There are elements of non-consent in this story. If that type of element offends you, or is problematic, please do not read. ### I couldn't believe it. Carlos . . . my friend . . . my brother . . . the hottest, sexiest man I'd ever known . . . was lying on my bed, sound asleep, and completely nude. Even though I felt guilty for doing it,...

Gym Workout: Rob, John, Ryan, & Coach

by whodominou on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

Author's Note: If you have not previously read my work, please keep an open mind to the unimaginable as there will be monster cocks, expanding bodies, cumflation, and much more. All characters are over the age of 18. Enjoy! ****** John Oberker looked himself over in his mirror at home before heading to school. His mom had already scolded him to wake up fo...

Mirror

by peleiades on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

The big man paced naked around the locker room, from mirror to locker and back, shaving, trimming, moisturizing. He was 35 and hard as a rock, tall, big-boned, and hairy. Jet black hair. His deep chest was wild with it, but it disappeared as it moved down toward his crotch, leaving his belly smooth. He had a small but thick bush of hair in his crotch. His di...

Mike's Meat Ch. 02

by dirtyword on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

For the next couple weeks I watched Mike, my straight bodybuilding housemate, walk around my house in his underwear. On the days Mike did his leg routine at the gym he would come back to the estate and pose for me like we had agreed to. This was one of the conditions for him to live here rent free. I got to feel his gorgeous legs at the end of each posing se...

Muscle and Breath Control

by muffinbod on Aug 17, 2017
Gay Male

This story is a treasure memory. I took to the gym in my late teens, having been a fat kid. Fat kids were rare in those days. I guess that being more numerous now, perhaps there is less stigma attached to being "The fat kid", maybe not but when I see so many obese children waddling about the supermarket and I remember how much effort it has taken to recover...

Aaron and Tank

by xythan shadow on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Aaron and Tank had worked together for almost eight years. They both were in construction and good friends, but they looked the exact opposites of each other. Aaron was around 5'2'' tall and chubby, weighing in at around 225 lbs. Tank was massive, 6'3'' and 250 lbs, but unlike Aaron, Tank was all ripped muscle. Unbeknownst to Tank though, Aaron was gay. Tank...

Skar and I Ch. 03: Ritual Fuck

by UlyssesMuscle on May 21, 2019
Gay Male

Skar pads over to the massage table and bends over, settling his bulk of his torso on it and splaying his ass. Matt moves closer to him, admiring the peaks and valleys of his obscenely muscle back. He is a mountain range of man. Matt moves around the table to stand at Skar's head, letting his massive, throbbing erection sway in front of his open mouth. He tr...

Last House on Fraternity Row Ch. 04

by texastank on May 7, 2019
Gay Male

Luke licked his lips as he stared at Rex's cock, slowly sliding in and out of Rex's fist. With the tour finally over and the gravity of where he was sinking in, he could finally fully focus on the horse cock hanging between Rex's legs. It was long and thick. By Luke's estimate it had to be at least eight inches, if not longer, with a slight upward curve. It...

Encounters with Evil Pt. 01

by roughboy18 on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Encounters with Evil © Copyright jvaughn, 2013. All rights reserved. Copyright violators will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. * Tigger focused carefully, squinting at the glass in his hand and willing his muscles to behave as he set the drink down slowly. In spite of his effort, he misjudged the distance and vodka and orange juice sloshed...

Dick - The Teen Gym Stud Ch. 04

by dominanceaddict1 on Nov 18, 2019
Gay Male

I was really confused about what had happened with Ryan. I wasn't gay! I had basically never had a gay thought in my life. That is, until huge muscle teen stud Ryan...Dick. And while it was almost definitely the case that Ryan knew the effect he had on me, I didn't know for sure that he did. He hadn't really reacted to my climax on top of him (other than to...