Gay Pastor Stories

469 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com

His Merciless Pastor

by Guy521 on Dec 24, 2019
Gay Male

Adam looked at the floor as Pastor Julian took a seat at the desk. No doubt his father had told the Pastor about what he had done. 'Look up at me son,' said Pastor Julian sternly. Adam looked up into Pastor Julian's eyes wishing the ground would swallow him up. He could see the disgust in the Pastor's eyes. Feel the judgement for the things he had done....

Elwood and His Gun Pt. 01

by newpaulman on Jul 15, 2020
Gay Male

Elwood Gunn was a pastor, the semi-trained, semi-legitimate, semi-genuine leader of a small religious community that met in what had once been a cinema on the Caribbean island of St Timothy. I had recently arrived and, looking to make some friends, had gone along on Sunday mornings. There was always this awkward moment when old Elwood or one of his crew aske...

Idolatria Ch. 02

by Asbel on Jul 17, 2019
Gay Male

You could tell how well Pastor Len thought his sermon went that day by how high he bounced on his feet during the benediction. If he thought it didn't go over well, he would only sort of pop up a tiny bit or rock on his heels. If he thought it was enjoyable, then he would hop up on the balls of his feet, hands outstretched and smile unrestrained, as he spoke...

Meeting My Love

by Jerseyshore on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I met Thomas through unusual circumstances. My former pastor and his wife invited me over to dinner to meet "another bachelor." I thought George knew I was gay as I had dropped a few hints in church, but I figured that this would be just a nice social event as I enjoyed the Peelen's company and figured the man would be interesting if nothing else. Have you...

Elwood and His Gun Pt. 02

by newpaulman on Sep 21, 2020
Gay Male

As described in part one, Elwood was a pastor on the Caribbean island of St Timothy, but I wasn't sure if he was genuine. I had already had sex with him once, a breathtaking session in which I had sucked his cock and he had wanked all over me. I wanted him to fuck me but he said I had to go home and think about it and then ask him. Talk about submissive: ju...

Canoe Trip to Heaven

by ramoredrake on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I had just graduated high school and was on a church sponsored trip in the Boundary Waters area of the Minnesota wilderness. I was hopelessly inexperienced and virginal 18 year old and was thrilled to learn that I would be sharing a two-man tent with a junior pastor in training named Bryce. The rest of our group were in three large, 8-man tents, but we were...

Homophobe

by drmweaver705 on Jan 22, 2020
Gay Male

All participants are over 18. ***** He knew one thing in life and that was that he hated fags because God hated fags. His pastor said so. Leviticus said so. Didn't everyone just know? Ralph sat naked in front of his computer at home in his parents' basement. He was of stocky build and he kept his head shaved close. Gays were the enemy of his way of life....

Jocks of the South Pt. 11

by scottgoulding123 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Sorry for the major delay in this chapter! September was a busy month for school. Thank you to everyone for their patience and I hope you enjoy reading it! :) *** The Perfect Fit The two boys ran out the back entrance of the church, giggling and laughing at one another as they sprinted through the tall grass and large, open fields. Francis was right—there...

Aquata Cove Ch. 93

by Feare909 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Alright, new chapter is up. Once again, haters on this website, if you want this story to stop, then move along, I can post whatever I want here. For those of you who like this story, I hope you enjoy - I'm a little uncertain with the structure of this chapter, it's kind of... Dodgy to me. Let me know what you think. ***** Chapter 93: Fleeting Distance...

Orgasm by Anal Penetration

by Eagerbottom on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I grew up in a Pentecostal family in Holland, but deled in silence with liking men. I get married with a woman and to my sadness after seven years I got divorced. Though I had not gone to church for a while, I started to go to one, in Amsterdam. I was already in my thirties. I did a bit of work out, but was too tiny to my taste. I liked to meet other people....