Gay Permanent Butt Plug Stories

8,265 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2025 SmutMD.com

Giving Up Control Ch. 01

by funguy2223 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Walking to the front door of your condo I notice the door is cracked and there is a note outside. The note reads "I expect you to be fully shaved and wearing your cock ring. I expect you to remain silent the entire time you are here except when you are gagging on my cock or my dildo. I expect you to enter my condo and close the door, then strip entirely nake...

Old Man Discovers... Ch. 09

by tnwriter on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Last sentence # 8...as I'm about to doze off... "I woke up a couple of hours later. Relaxed and satisfied. As I lay there I remembered back to several days earlier when Fred, rang my doorbell. He said we should come to a permanent decision about our future. He had made a decision and I had made a decision about us—couple of old guys getting it on. So I gues...

Confronting His Lies Ch. 03

by amasterfound on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Fa, Ma/Ma, Consensual, Reluctant, Gay, BiSexual, Heterosexual, BDSM, DomSub, MaleDom, Spanking, Rough, Sadistic, Oral Sex, Anal Sex, Masturbation, Sex Toys, Exhibitionism, Voyeurism, Size. This was written by SEVERUSMAX and myself. ***** "This is definitely not over, Ward. Now, get on yo...

Influencer to Sex Slave Ch. 05

by dreamymark9 on Jul 30, 2019
Gay Male

Author's note: This is erotic fantasy and completely fictional. The main character, Jack, is a fictional, generic social media star / influencer, and is not a real person. As always, would love to get feedback in comments and messages. Today was Jack's first day as a sex slave when his master was at work, and it was pretty eventful. He got a ton of embarras...

The Boy At My Door... Ch. 03

by funguy2223 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

It's been ten days since this teen boy first knocked at my door. I remember when I first looked through the peephole to see proof that he was legal and had shaven his thin eighteen year old body for me. He was such an innocent boy in that first moment, so horny and so inexperienced. How was he to know that what I had been doing to him was anything other than...

College Judo Ch. 05

by reddirtwriter on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

The three of us became a . . . well trio I guess. Shane and I paired up on a regular basis, and occasionally I got that itch that he scratched so well. Sometimes Shane would bring Marc, and he was always eager to play. His initial exposure to man-on-man sex might have been on the rough side, but he didn't seem to mind. There was a rhythm to it all and everyo...

'Til The Cows Come Home

by marux on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

Nathan headed out of his house with a big grin. Working the farm always made him happy. It was really the cow shed that did it, which was the main reason he'd had to sell off most of his fields to his neighbors. He just liked being with the "cows" more than on the land. But that was OK, their milk sold for quite a pretty penny, and his father had taught him...

Always, Forever and a Day Ch. 02

by Baby789 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

If you haven't read The Day It All Changed and Always Forever and a Day please read them first. Thank you feedback appreciated. * Tyler groaned and sighed, stretching as he woke up, he stomach cramped and he was soaked with his own sweat. "How are you, Tiger?" Matt murmured next to his ear. Tyler had came down with a bad case of the flu and Matt had been...

Ben is Kept Under Control Ch. 04

by verdunsears on Mar 26, 2019
Gay Male

Robert had come over to my apartment on Saturday night and I'd spent most of the time since being tied up with a butt plug up my ass or sucking his cock or swallowing his piss or being fucked or spanked. Now it was late on Sunday afternoon and just as I was about to get another beating, he stopped to make a long-distance phone call. I was confused and annoy...

The Hanky Code Pt. 05: Sub to Gay Pig

by His_fag_wife on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

I then heard the unmistakable snap of latex gloves going onto a hand, then felt Steve's hand moving around my butt, it was slick with some liquid and he pushed between the saddle and my ass trying to touch all of my ass and even tightly around the base of the plug. He was having to force his hand in to lift each cheek momentarily from the saddle to coat them...