Gay Pony Play Stories

9,558 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Doctor Knows Best Ch. 01

by Wynneboi on Sep 16, 2017
Gay Male

When did this get out of hand? Personally I haven't a god damn clue! Though there are plenty of hints and moments in which seemed to speed these 'event's' along. But all said and done there are 'three' people to blame. One of them was me, one of them was my therapist, and the last was my attorney. They make a lovely pair but oddly enough they have, NO FUCKI...

The Carny Pt. 02

by bhart1 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Part Two: We reached the fairgrounds by a quarter to nine. "Go help Larry fire up the generators. That's him over at the Ferris Wheel. After that just do whatever looks like it needs doing, and don't be afraid to ask if you're not sure. It's all about teamwork!" "On my way!" I wanted to prove myself to the big man in the worst way and was scared to death...

Mister Charles

by exaucer on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The summer of 1976 was especially hot. It was late August and I was studying in the library at college but found it impossible to concentrate. Every time I looked out of the window I could see carefree people in the quad, laughing, enjoying life, making the most of the wonderful, warm weather. I felt left behind, stuck in this mausoleum reading but not takin...

Remembering When... Ch. 03

by ssremember129 on Oct 15, 2017
Gay Male

Ray went off the radar for five days since our last fuck session. I left him two messages just to see if he was willing to fuck again. Yet, his comment when we parted about the potential to add a few of his friends to our new found sex replayed over and over in my mind. I had no experience with multiple women let alone multiple men. Still, was I reading too...

Old and Bold

by papadomi on Oct 22, 2019
Gay Male

Already in senior high school, I was fantasizing about my teachers. Especially the not so young ones, in their fifties or so. Mating with a mature male, this was the most extreme sexual experience I could possibly think of. For many years though, I never considered doing it for real. It happened that older men would cast unambiguous looks at me now and then....

Sail to the Sun Ch. 08

by sr71plt on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Life was little different in the mansion hugging the snow-clad mountainside at Snowshoe than it was in Hoagie's inn. Less demanding—in terms of service both at table and in the bed—and the surroundings certainly more sumptuous. But very little different in terms of feeling owned and controlled—and isolated, all alone in the world. I cursed Buddy nearly daily...

No Wonder He's So Cocky

by dixeenormous on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

As a college freshman at a state school in the Rocky Mountains, I was a pretty conservative guy, especially considering all the boozing, drugs, and wild sex that was running rampant in my coed dorm. My high school years were very low key; I had dated the same girl since sophomore year, swam competitively, and studied hard. At university, I was in way over my...

Mew's Meow

by KissMeLikeYouMeanIt on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

~And that, friends, is how to make a quick sausage and potato feast. Don't burn your fingers!~ I sighed and logged out of the blog. "Mew's Meows" was my pathetic attempt at opening up to people. My therapist had suggested it, telling me that the anonymity of the 'net might make me spill my guts since obviously his sessions weren't helping. I'd grudgingly ag...

Puff Adder Pt. 02

by anaidmap on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Oliver "Meet me at the car park in five. I'm the red Shelby. Heading home early." Hmm, weird, An leaving school early? Wow, she hadn't bunked a class since high school… Maybe she couldn't wait to see me. I couldn't wait either, so I moved into a jog towards the car park with my phone still in my hand. When I made it there I couldn't help but laugh....

The Talent Scout

by eviltwin52 on Jun 5, 2019
Gay Male

The day I first met him was like any other day. Riding the Metro to work I was suddenly jostled out of my reverie by some one bumping into me from the back. Turning I found myself looking up at a ruggedly handsome man. His steely grey/blues seemed to pierce into my very being. I wanted to look away but was unable to do so. After a few seconds that seemed to...