Gay Pony Play Stories

9,558 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Becoming a Gal Friday Pt. 05-06

by Showoff888 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Oh my god! I'm naked except for a pair of slutty fire truck red platform high heels, you know the kind you call 'fuck me shoes'. I'm on a bed with David this great looking black guy and Saul, his white gay curly brown hair partner, with the dashing goatee, kind of a Jewish swashbuckler thing going with that goatee. Saul and David are built tall and solidly m...

Cowboy Lust

by Humilifuck on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

It is a brutally hot day in Texas, the heat relents only slightly as the sun sinks below the horizon. Wandering into a bar for a cold drink, I find myself out of place among a sea of plaid shirts and oversized belt buckles. Strange noises from a back-room attract my attention. Peeking through the doorway, I discover a completely dark room except for the oc...

A Gentlemen's Agreement Ch. 07

by kwchancellor on Aug 28, 2017
Gay Male

I awoke when Tyler shifted his position next to me and realized I needed to take a piss something fierce. He was using the crook of my shoulder as a pillow, and I didn't want to disturb him, but saw no way out of it. Slowly, carefully, I pulled myself away from him. He woke up, rolling over in bed to look at me. "What's happening?" he mumbled, almost incohe...

Chico's Delight

by BatteryOperated on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Ted's parents still didn't know that he had dropped out of college. They had really high expectations for him: getting a job, paying his own rent...it was just too hard and three more years of school wasn't what he wanted. So Ted decided to lay low for a while and live off of the left over tuition money they'd given him the previous semester while he worked...

A Rape in the Belfry Ch. 09

by Decayed Angel on Sep 16, 2017
Gay Male

After getting cleaned up and dressed, Rocco and I took a ride in the police cruisers back to the police station. Once we were fingerprinted, photographed and booked, they moved us to the back into some holding cells. Since it was already early evening on a Friday, it looked like these holding cells would be home for the weekend. Fortunately, although we were...

Darnell

by ThurstonMann on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

How it is that we eventually choose what we like is beyond me. There seems to be no rhyme or reason to the whole mess of being straight, bi or gay and add to that the subtle taste differences that come with those different varieties of connections. I might not know why I like what I like... but I know what I like and this is the story of Darnell. I was nine...

Oh What A Night

by Erotica_Writings on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I am looking at my brothers wedding pictures and still cannot believe what he confided in me last night. We were sitting at a very elegant restaurant with soft music and a very charming waiter named Alexus, he wore a white ruffled long sleeve shirt, black pirate pants with a red sash and black boots, his hair was long and black that was pulled back into a po...

A New Year a New Me

by Sean Renaud on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Well everybody you'll have to forgive me. I normally write stories not accounts so this is a bit awkward for me but there doesn't seem to be another way to tell this story. I can't sit back tell this story like it happened so somebody else because it didn't. It happened to me and I can't sit back and tell this like it was some kind of story I made up about s...

Boys Week At The Cabin Ch. 03

by 09cutter on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Monday morning, Anna and her mom took one Escalade, and Mark and I took the other. We were headed to the cabin my great grandfather built. Anna and my wife were going to the college that Anna planned on attending in the fall. My sons may join Mark and I later in the week. Even with all that had passed between Mark and I, the trip was nothing unusual. Idle c...

In Bed with The Boss Man Ch. 03

by andy190 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

So now I was a top as well. And all this in a week! What would Marty think back at work when I told him. If I told him. I stepped out of the shower and found that Tony was no longer asleep. He sat on the end of the bed and was deep in a mobile phone conversation. He winked at me and grinned as he continued. "Sure you'll like him. He's a really cute guy. B...