Gay Scare Stories

1,022 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Bait a Hook Ch. 02

by VaRiverWriter on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter 2: New Beginnings We left before the moving truck, trusting that they would finish loading up and get on the road as soon as possible. My parents each drove their own car; they decided the best route would be through Maryland and across the Bay Bridge onto the Delmarva Peninsula and then all the way to almost the end of peninsula. After searching ma...

Coming Home Ch. 02

by roychelray on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Kane: I run through a maze of exploding mines, desperate to reach the end. All around me I see blurs of men in digi's, guns screaming as they fire on each other. I stumble and slam face first into sand. I struggle to get up but the sand keeps dragging me back down. Finally I manage to yank myself free, but when I look down, I'm covered blood. It's happening...

David Gill Ch. 02

by StackShotBilly on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

(All main characters are over the age of 18) * I was reading about Cthulhu and the Old Ones when the sound of the shower being shut off made me suddenly remember whose book I was reading. I put the book back on Matthew's bed and stood up. As soon as my my feet hit the floor the door to the bathroom opened and a figure stepped out, looking at the ground th...

Pineapples & Chocolate

by emlynley on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Ben sighed impatiently as he wheeled his shopping cart around the small grocery store around the corner from his apartment. He tossed a few random items into his cart, eyes constantly scanning, taking in everything--and everyone--around him. He needed something to satisfy his craving. Nothing in his cart. He was hungry, but it wasn't for food. Instead, he w...

King University's New Slut Ch. 04

by BlaqJm18 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The clock buzzed loud and I jerked up from my pillow. I turned it off and laid there. I didn't sleep good at all with my throat still sore from that 11 inch dick that buried itself down my throat. It was all because of Quinn. I hated him, I hated what he had he had done to me. I wanted to tell someone but I was too scaried that Quinn might find out and do mo...

Brotherly Love

by sexyinaf on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

I pulled up in our driveway after a long week of college. It was my sophomore year in college and classes were a bitch now that the intro classes were out of the way. I always look forward to going home on the weekends, but this one was particularly special. I walked in the door and saw my little brother eating a bowl of ice cream. He had his back to me so...

Life: It Gets Better Ch. 02

by TheRealThingg on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Still no sex, but things do get hot. Please send me feedback if there's anything wrong with this story, or you want to help me improve it. Please and thank you. LadyBugg- * I woke up to the smell of coffee and bacon. Laura was rushing in the kitchen cursing loudly. "Fuck! My boss is going to have my ass." She could never be on time for anything. I'm surp...

High School Hottie Ch. 01

by HeyThere4455 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

How did I, a small, brown-haired, 5 foot 11, high school senior, end up with the hottest, most popular boy in school? Well, it still remains somewhat a mystery, even to me. My name is Josh McDonnell and I am 18 years old. I'm in Grade 12 of High School at East Mountain High, and last month, while walking down the hall with one of my best friends, it all sta...

Influencer to Sex Slave Ch. 06

by dreamymark9 on Dec 24, 2019
Gay Male

Author's note: This is erotic fantasy and completely fictional. The main character, Jack, is a fictional, generic social media star / influencer, and is not a real person. Apologizes I haven't written in a while, but thanks for the comments and messages. They really give me ideas and encourage me to keep going! ***** Jack reflects on how he went from being...

Fritz & Greg's Rooming House Ch. 02

by drmweaver705 on Feb 3, 2020
Gay Male

My drunken Friday night encounter with Greg was my first ever gay sexual experience and I quickly decided it would not be my last. That first quickie was followed by another hour of passion later that night. We went to my room where I enjoyed Fritz's sloppy seconds willingly. I heaved myself at Greg's ass, hammering until I came hard. It must have felt good...