Gay Scare Stories

1,022 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Long Hair & Lace Panties

by Obzezzion on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

The name's Michael. I'm an Irish boy from nowhere in particular, and the bright-red ponytail I wear is more than enough proof of that. I dress well enough when I need to; my work wardrobe usually consists of black wingtips, tight-fitting black slacks that are a little loose around the knees to allow for bending, and a dark solid button-down. I'm a relatively...

Dreaming Ch. 03

by 12inCCrunner on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

At 6:50 I was standing in front of Barnes & Noble waiting for Eric to get there. I was nervous as hell. What if he doesn’t show? What if he does, but then backs down? I had never been this nervous on a date before, but then I’d never been on a date with another guy. I’d been on dates with women before, and had had sex with other guys, but never dated. Add...

Seduced by a Younger Man

by Corjix on Jun 9, 2020
Gay Male

This is a fantasy story, with no condom, bareback sex. Always protect yourself in real life! All characters are over 18...well over 18! * * * * * My age? Suffice to say, I am on the other side of fifty. I bear the sorrow of one who has wasted the better part of his life. For reasons not germane to this story, I had my same-sex initiation very late in life...

Fucked Behind Bars

by REINER BENT on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Back where I come from a misdemeanor can get you to jail if it's repeated for three times in a row. I was stupid enough to commit the same petty offence three times and I had to stay three months in prison. Those were the worst three months of my whole life... In the beginning I could not believe I had been imprisoned. What was I doing with all these crimin...

When the Broken Pieces... Pt. 01

by olivewalnut23 on Jul 17, 2019
Gay Male

Levi POV Levi was just getting out of the shower when he heard the knock at his door. He wondered who would be at my house at 11o'clock at night after he had just gotten off work late and dirty. I was helping a farmer who's building had caught on fire we were getting out as many of the pigs that we could save then we had to go roundup any pigs we could find...

Portly Cumming

by ChewToySub on Apr 24, 2018
Gay Male

I stood outside my arranged meet's front door, waiting for what seemed like a mini eternity before I heard the slow footsteps approaching from inside. I would later realise, with a clearer head, it was only a few seconds on that doorstep, but the butterflies fluttering in my stomach have the effect of stretching out time far beyond that of reality. "Hey son...

Acting the Part

by whields on Mar 6, 2018
Gay Male

Aaron had always enjoyed acting, for him it was a way to escape real life and enter a whole new world, fully immersing himself into the character he was playing. So, when he moved away to university, the am-dram group was the first one he'd signed up to. In his first term, the group had performed a play that he had only a small part in, but as the year prog...

To Serve Him Ch. 01

by Whenitsneverending on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

The first day of my college experience, I was eighteen. Because of the Advanced Placement programs at my high school I was entering the college world with my Freshman year already done. That meant no freshman hazing. No last picks for classes. No stupid Freshman only rules. It was gonna be great. I decided not to join a fraternity until I got into the flow...

Dreams Can Cum True

by curiousandkinky on Oct 8, 2019
Gay Male

It was a day no different than any other. I got home early and was relaxing with a drink and my laptop while everyone else was still sleeping. It may be 3am but for me it is my evening. I see my friend's son Jacob is online so I send him a message. After a few messages he asks me if I was at work and tell him I am at home with a drink in hand. He asks if he...

The Forest Ch. 01

by Robyboyrob on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

I woke up as usual when my alarm went off at 8AM, but that's just about the only thing that's the same right now. I gave a big yawn and looked at all the boxes in my room. I fell back in my pillow with a thud as the realisation sets in again. I left everything I know and loved back in California, since my dad now has a new job in Cliffdell Washington. After...