Gay Scare Stories

1,022 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Right Place, Wrong Time

by LilJacks on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

It was a bright, sunny day. Probably about 100 degrees, maybe more. 19 year old Harry Gordon waded through the tall weeds in the dense forest. The smell of nature filled his nostrils, and sweat formed all over his muscular body, which was under a pair of denim jeans and a thin T-shirt. He wiped his forehead with his hand, and swept the short strands of brown...

Rudy's Story

by Ranefox on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The bar had closed at two a.m. With six-pack in hand, I was in search of an after-hours gathering. As I drove down Railroad Avenue, I saw a figure in the darkness, leaning against an abandoned building. He was not alone. The closer I got, I saw that a second man knelt in front of him. As I passed directly in front of them, I recognized the man who stood in...

Pheonix Shadow

by BixbiteQueen97 on Dec 24, 2019
Gay Male

(AN: This story is a little slow building. This chapter has some sex in it, don't worry, but a little bit of world-building is due before that.) I plaster a convincing grin on my face as I walk around to wait tables. I hate bright days like this. So many shadows around me whispering into my mind... some louder than others. It's the loud ones that scare me....

Jake and Toby Ch. 06

by kmillerk1 on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Author Note: I wrote this Jack part almost right after I wrote the first chapter of this story. I have been waiting until I thought it was time to insert it. So here it is. Thank you for the comments, public and private, I do enjoy reading them. ************** **Toby** The Doc and I were walking up to the ER doors from the parking structure and there st...

Romeo and Tre Ch. 01

by Black2Passion on Aug 22, 2017
Gay Male

Today was Romeo's first day at Georgia State University. Romeo is mixed with African American and Dominican; he has green eyes, light skin, nice curly brown hair, skinny and a little muscular, and attractive. He is a gay male but he has kept that a secret through his high school years by doing track. Romeo went to his dorm and was happy to see his friend C...

Should Have Known Better

by knowsbetter on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

A beautiful spring day, one of those early warm ones where suddenly there's a lot of unexpected skin everywhere, and you can't not look, and I'm stuck at the library studying. Girls are lying out in the sun untying their bikini tops and I cannot focus. The buzzing of too much coffee and not enough sleep and oh god those shorts she's wearing are so small. J...

First Time Meeting

by therookie on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

At 24 I had been curious for some time about what it would feel like to suck a cock. I was pretty sure I wasn't gay, but the idea of doing it got me really hot. I started surfing around on the internet some, reading gay porn, even watching some. And that only made me more interested. So I started placing personal ads on some sites and chatting late at night....

Fear, Confusion...Love? Ch. 04

by RightfullyWrong on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Tony practically skipped into work that evening. He was so excited. He was going to be able to tell Mark he had his money back AND that the guy who'd attacked him was going to be far too scared to go after anyone else! "You're looking happy" smiled Mark as Tony walked into the office "I am! I have some great news!" said Tony grabbing Mark and kissing him....

Seduction Ch. 01

by massagetherapy on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

As I handed the clerk my money, he half-heartedly wished me a nice time. Yes, I thought, I certainly intend on having one. Walking into the pitch-black theater, I thought about how long it’d been since I’d been here. Lately work had taken way too much of my time and I really was glad I had taken the day off. I enjoy watching porn at home as much as the nex...

Meeting the New Neighbor

by chaoticlsd on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Cade couldn't believe what was happening, here he was mouth open salivating over Mr. Waters 9 inch, thick cock. He licked his lips lifted his right hand and gripped the base getting a firm grasp. He could feel Mr. Waters pulse throbbing through the thickness. Mr. Waters or shall I say Kip rested his hand on top of Cade's head, firmly applying pressuring. Cad...