Gay Scare Stories

1,022 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Alpha Roommate

by XeNoS_25 on Feb 12, 2019
Gay Male

Why on God's green earth am I being transferred to a school for shifters. I'm just a typical human on a bit of the small side, I'm 5'5, skinny with faded muscles and I weight about 115 lbs. Pathetic right, I'll be some shifter's protein shake the moment they catch my scent. They said I'll only be there for 3 months, something about improving human/shifter...

My First M2M Experience Pt. 02

by mikurt on Mar 16, 2020
Gay Male

...continued from my first submission This is still a very true story of how I was slowly seduced by an older man when I was a bi curious college student. * After that night in his apartment when he spit on his hard cock while we watched porn, I couldn't get my mind off of that image and what could have been. I also couldn't wait to get back there alone...

Delivery Boy Seduction

by drmweaver705 on Sep 28, 2020
Gay Male

All participants are 18 or over. ***** I knew what to expect when Mr. Collins came into the store. He usually winked and waved in my direction and let his eyes hold mine for several seconds longer than felt normal. He usually managed to stand behind me for a bit while I swept the floors or stocked the shelves with canned goods. I never knew how to respond...

Here to Stay Ch. 01

by tml_writer on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

"Hey, Matt? I can't tell which one of these shirts is the black one," Emmett Clark shouted frustratedly across the apartment while trying to feel the difference in the fabrics over and over again. He heard Matt's footsteps start down the hall. "Whoa, man, put some jeans on. You know you're not my type," Matt joked, walking through the doorway seeing Emmett...

A Change of Heart for Leander Ch. 02

by RobMontague on Sep 19, 2017
Gay Male

Noah: you out this weekend gorgeous? x x x Nile: Not this weekend no, with my girlfriend for the weekend. x Noah: Mmm lucky girl. x x x Nile rolled his eyes and stuffed the phone into his pocket. Noah was certainly interested in him, nothing he did put him off. He had tried not replying but then felt bad so caved in. He sighed and let himself into Jasmine...

My Personal Journey Ch. 01

by Cindyforsin on Jul 4, 2018
Gay Male

I parked my car in the lot and sat staring out into the dark park. I started thinking about what I planned to do and considered leaving. During high school, I never seemed to fit in. I dated a few girls, but the dates never developed into a relationship. One of the girls kissed me goodnight, but it was the extent of my contact. I never participated in spor...

One Man's Search Ch. 02

by Tarielen on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter 2 -- Savior Reggie felt his body slam against the boy's lean frame as he wrapped his arms around him and threw them both out of the car's path. He turned himself as to catch the man and absorb the impact of the landing. His heard his trench coat tear against the pavement and winced slightly. After a moment of laying there he glanced down into his ar...

My Neighbor Matt

by DudesDudes on Aug 17, 2017
Gay Male

Matt is my neighbor in the townhouse across from mine. He's a lot like me. Mid thirties, around 6' tall, thin, glasses. Kind of a geeky type. We never really talked other than the usual "Hey" or wave when we saw each other out in the driveway. I'm not even sure how I found out his name. I could tell he was a geeky type like me because he appeared to enjoy t...

Sometimes Things Just Happen

by jpro56 on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

I wasn't really looking to hook up with anyone that morning, but when I saw him strolling through the store, he caught my attention. There wasn't anything special about him, just an instant thing that I felt. I followed him around for a few moments, watching his ass and thinking about what it might look like without those tight jeans covering it. He often tu...

Martin

by KurtWaldman on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I met Martin at a popular gay bar in town. He was a handsome man in his mid-forties (about 20 years older than I). We shared a laugh over a highly intoxicated couple involved in a heavy petting make out session on the dance floor. He bought me a beer and when I raised to clink my bottle in appreciation, I noticed his wedding ring. "Does your wife know you a...