Gay Shame Stories

2,988 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Daddy Issues

by Ananius on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

It shouldn't have taken him so long. The first thought that ran through Alex's head as he stood on the front porch of the stranger's house was how he couldn't believe it had taken him this long to choose to submit to a man. He was 21. How long had these fantasies been playing through his head? How many times had he almost taken the plunge and met up with so...

Cheating on Our Wives

by StephanieSeymour93 on Jul 15, 2020
Gay Male

The moment my cock slipped inside his asshole I knew it was the real deal. We were going bareback. Neither of us gave a fuck, and we were both married anyway, so the risk was low. He was on his stomach on the bed where he fucked his wife a night earlier. Now it was my turn, and I wasn't holding anything back. I was on top, pumping him. He wore his wife's lac...

An Unwanted, Warm Welcome

by new_in_town_404 on Mar 16, 2020
Gay Male

We had been texting for a few days now, and we were finally making plans to meet. "So, what are you thinking?" "A bar sounds good!" He just turned 21 a few months ago, so he's still really excited about being able to go out. "Alright... I'm new in town so let me look this up." "Looks like there's a gay bar about halfway between us. 'The Alley'." "I'll...

Str8 Teams's Secret Gay Sex Tea Ch.02

by GGandG on Sep 25, 2017
Gay Male

Coach Smith was balls deep inside his 19 year old red headed fuck puppet when everyone in the shower started groaning. Water splashed against the milky white skin over Cory's muscular back. The coach shoved his fat red cock in and out of Cory's tight ass. The skin of his shaft pulled tight back and forth as he thrust in and out the young man's butt. Cory's h...

My Shame

by justinsshame on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

We would often go to the gay club to hit on girls who were hiding from straight men, ironic I know. Well, in Salem, the bars didn't close until 2:30 am. My friends were bored of the speak easy, so they ended up leaving. I told them I would just take a cab home. The night was ending, and as always, people, me included, were looking for after parties. Two gu...

My Wife Hands Me Over to My Dom Ch. 01

by FantasizeAndRealize on Feb 6, 2018
Gay Male

I had been happily married for almost ten years when my wife, Susan, discovered I was having a gay affair with Carl. Our married life was good and loving, we had three little kids and I truly loved my wife both emotionally and sexually. It was just that I craved cock occasionally, too. After Susan got over the initial shock we sat down and talked. I confesse...

What If You are the Whirlwind? Ch. 01

by Sublissimal on Jan 23, 2019
Gay Male

"Imagine for a moment, if you would A life that's not defined in bad and good But chained instead with shameful aching need To eat the fruit and try to hide the seed." ___ Carver ___ Carver stands on the porch steps, arm around his wife Sandra waving goodbye to Sam and Shelly, the last couple to leave Bible study group. As they pull away from the curb...

Merrit's Merits Ch. 02

by Heartgrind on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Two young men were in a bedroom together, sunlight falling upon them from the window. They were both Caucasian, about nineteen or twenty years of age. The taller one sat on the bed, with his legs folded in the lotus position. His dirty blond hair was madly gelled, spikes bristling in all directions. In his left hand, he held a spherical puzzle of carefully...

Humiliation

by AgentK on Oct 15, 2017
Gay Male

"Renton Elliott Abernathy, come to the front of the classroom, please." Renton stood and did as his teacher asked, his eyebrows raised in curiosity. "Such a shame, isn't it, that the most talented young mage in his class is also an arrogant, disobedient little brat? Perhaps a severe punishment will help you realize the error of your ways." Renton looked e...

The Soccer Bitch Ch. 02

by LDNBTM21 on Oct 15, 2017
Gay Male

PART 2 It had been about 4 months since the events at Jay’s house. I hadn't heard from Jay at all in those months, and started to forget about the whole events. I started to feel more at ease with myself, but didn't plan on playing for the team again. Over the summer I’d managed to get myself a job waiting tables at a local diner, and was making a reasona...