Gay Shemale Surprise Stories

7,774 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

A Night at the Movie turned me Gay Pt. 02

by jamtby on Oct 12, 2020
Gay Male

Entering the room immediately caused my stomach to churn with excitement. Something about entering a place where strangers are in control and you anticipate being involved with sexual activities. The what, why, and how remained a mystery. This only added to the combination of nervousness and excitement. The woman with a strangely deep voice said, "Welcome...

Kinky Tales: Many Cocks to Suck

by silkstockingslover on Jun 19, 2018
Gay Male

Summary: Straight guy finds a theatre where anything gay goes. Note 1: This is part 5 of a potentially lengthy series about a couple exploring many aspects of their once-hidden sexuality. Part 1 was told in two separate versions: To read the wife's version read: Kinky Tales: I Pegged my Husband In this story Dani accidentally learns that her husband has...

Sex with an Old Man

by johnthome7690 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Before I start I should give you some background on myself. I also want it to be known that this story is 100% non fiction. If you like the story, contact me via contact tab. I am a mostly straight man. I never have, and still after, the incident I am about to tell you about, am not attracted to men. I never walk past a guy on the streets and want him sexual...

Curious and Horny - 22m

by toddmac781 on Dec 25, 2018
Gay Male

One night a few years ago, bored and horny as usual, I found myself stroking my cock to some porn and decided to peruse Craigslist. The usual posts were there. Old guys trying to find some younger cock, a few weirdos, and the usual straight guys testing the waters. One post stood out to me. 'Curious and horny-22m.' I clicked on it and very frankly he expla...

Becoming a bitch

by Testytesterton on Nov 28, 2019
Gay

(Skip this if you don't like boring behind the scenes stuff. Wow! Over 3000 likes and story of the week for my first story here! Thanks to everyone who has liked, bookmarked or commented. The feedback lets me know what works and what might need work. I would love for this to be the most popular story in its category, so if you like the story, "like&quot...

Open in Reader

My Inner Slut Ch. 06

by SlutAlexR on Oct 30, 2018
Gay Male

Daddy had been gone for a few days. He was away on a business trip. We communicated frequently, and he reminded me a few times that he had a surprise for me this coming Friday. So I waited anxiously for the end of the week. On Friday morning, I received a text: "Hello luv. I have been in contact with your Owner. We will pick you up at 6 tonight. But be ready...

Mind of Straight Married Cocksucker

by silkstockingslover on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Summary: The 10-part philosophy of a straight cocksucker. DISCLAIMER: This story is based on a couple years of research and conversations with straight men who are curious or are cocksuckers. Although I am female, I find a man sucking cock hot, I suppose like most men find two women hot. Thus, I thought I would, based on my many conversations with straight...

My Old Pal Charley

by MrSperm on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Longtime reader, this is my 1st literary submission. It is mostly a true story. ***** In my 30s I reconnected w/ an old high school chum on a whole other level. We had been friends on and off over the years, but I never let most people (esp the crowd i went to school with) know that I was bi. Well, an in the closet bisexual cocksucker to be exact. So this...

Adult Video Store

by bisuffolkguy on Apr 17, 2019
Gay Male

So I've come along way since my ass stretcher butt plug and dildo play. I use an extra-large butt plug daily, and have begun aggressively stretching my ass every chance I get. Dildos have progressed to large vegetables such as butternut squash and water bottles like Core and Smart Water. Its amazing with enough lube, you can get just about anything up your a...

Fixing the straights

by cdbaby on Dec 28, 2016
Gay

You wake up and prepare for your day, unaware that this would be the last day you would be considered straight. You shower as you did every morning and felt the water's warm touch as it cascaded over your skin. You could stay here forever if you could. But you need to start your day and the hot water would run out before long. You wash your hair, then the re...

Open in Reader