Gay Size Contest Stories

7,129 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

The Highland Festival Ch. 05: The Bar

by BareBearsFan on Apr 3, 2019
Gay Male

Chapter 5 -- Highland Festival -- The Bar ***Hello Readers Quick note, my stories tend to progress a bit slower, if you're looking for quick paced sex scenes try another story. This story contains nonconsensual sexual acts. Also, some past people have nitpicked about small consistency details in my stories. I'm not writing a classic novel, I'm not goin...

Carl and Matt Meet in Jamaica

by alphafan on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

Carl is a popular male nude photo model. He had just finished a photo shoot in Jamaica and decided to stay over a couple of days to enjoy the sun a bit before going back to New York. He was staying at a fantastic resort and decided to head over to the pool to catch a few rays. At the pool he checked out the crowd and spotted a huge muscular guy sitting off b...

James Reveals More than Expected

by sweetcobs84 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Will and I had been going to 47 Central in Lynn nearly every Saturday night for 2-3 years now. I guess you could call us "regulars". It was a nice neighborhood bar, with a very friendly (and hot) Brazilian bartender, a great DJ for dancing, and cheap drink prices, which more than outweighed the fact that the owner of the bar, George, was a persistent flirt....

The Contest

by Bunvotey11 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

It was now on between us. One of us was going to be a winner, and the other would suffer a messy and humiliating defeat. Me and my jackoff buddy Brad were matched pretty evenly, especially where it comes to being kinky. We started off earlier as friends throughout school, but we didn't know back then that we were both could be interested in each other. It'...

We Love It When You're Intoxicated

by LoveIsUniversal on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Emily felt so fortunate that this only happened once every few weeks. She and her boyfriend would visit their favorite sports bar and have a few drinks while watching the game in high definition. She didn't mind the aggressive competition displayed on the television screen. It became something that she most anticipated when visiting the place. What she could...

The New Roomate

by smally on Sep 17, 2017
Gay Male

I was beginning my junior year at college when it happened. I had a 2 bedroom dorm all to myself for the first 2 weeks of the semester. I loved the privacy and had my girlfriend, Cindy, over whenever I wanted. I was kicking back one late afternoon, when I got a call from Pam Clarkson at the office of university housing. She told me that another student need...

Rocky Horror Redux

by JKendallDane on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Dr. Randy Wolfe, PhD, stared with purpose into the bathroom mirror as he applied the last bit of near fluorescent, ruby red lipstick to his mouth. Setting it aside, he used a piece of toilet paper as a blotter to dab away any excess, then stepped back to admire his handiwork. Suddenly his deep voice began to reverberate off the walls and ceiling of the small...

Cumshot Contest

by crayrei on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

I'm an average guy, average in build, looks, and height, so I'm not exactly proud of my body. On top of that, I'm incurably shy, which explains why I'm still a virgin at 25. But the one thing I am actually proud of is my cock. It's pretty big, if I do say so myself, and best of all, I've always been able to cum really hard--I'm talking distance, volume, and...

What I'd Always Wanted

by Luctari on Aug 30, 2017
Gay Male

It's not like I had that much sex before my divorce. My wife was never really into it and, frankly, with her cold-fish approach, it didn't do that much for me either. So for most of my life, my sex life has consisted of beating off once a week or so. I've just never been one of those guys who's much good at getting what he wants, never really have been much...

The Cowboy vs Big Cock Indians

by silkstockingslover on Dec 1, 2017
Gay Male

Summary: The shocking truth of the old west finally told. Note 1: This is a special western themed story created by the lovely Black Randi. Thanks to Tex Beethoven, Black Randi, thor_p, Robert, and Wayne for editing this strange attempt. PS: Western is not my forte so please don't judge me too much on this story. Cowboys & Big Cock Indians History i...