Gay Straight First Time Stories

22,593 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Black Cock Party Ch. 09

by MarkLazer on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

After that fraternity house hookup, I went home for Christmas and returned back to campus on the 28th. Most everyone was off campus, even the athletes. The football team was playing in one of those lesser bowl games on that same day. Vinny, our starting linebacker who was black, built like a muscular god with the biggest cock I have ever had, called me that...

A Slap Too Far

by alexcarr on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

For the very first time I clamped during Jeff's fuck. I just stiffened and stopped responding. He was puffing and panting and almost there but the fact is he was bloody well hurting me, he was talking me a little too much for granted. Okay - so we had frequently enjoyed the rough fuck with handcuffs and his briefs tied around my face - and yes it was rather...

A River's Bluff

by zackjack on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The frigid river water enveloping my body shocked the senses more so as my unsubmerged head remained exposed to the scorching midday heat of the central Texas Hill Country. The dichotomy of sensations provided welcome respite from the vigorous summer hike over the verdant hills juxtaposed around the Sabinal River. My comrade "hiker-in-crime", Howard, a cons...

Straight Cop Loses Control

by Coxswain on Oct 22, 2019
Gay Male

Straight Cop Loses Control Gulf Coast Trooper craves the bottom Most folks passing a State Trooper cruiser parked beside a county road will slow down and hope they're not doing anything illegal. If they're in southern Alabama, none suspect what waits inside that patrol car, champing at the bit, restless, growling, eager get out, to go wild. Ever been to G...

My First Homosexual Experience

by ndbeckman701 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I was extremely nervous, this was not the first time I had made arrangements to meet a guy I'd met online through an ad I had posted on Craigslist but after over 5 years of progressively intensifying curiosity I finally let that yearning to know how it felt to have another man inside me outweigh my apprehensive fear of anyone I knew finding out about it. I h...

The Masseur

by littlesquirt on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I'm not gay. At least that is what I keep telling myself. In high school I played football in the fall, wrestled during the winter, played baseball in the spring/summer. Lettered in all three sports. I was popular with the girls, had a couple of steady girlfriends throughout high school, and in between always had a girl with me. I attended a small college wh...

Tad and Jeremy

by MistressMerry on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Jeremy sat on the couch thinking of his best friend Tad and knowing he was going to miss him. They grew up next door to each other and had gone through everything together all their lives up until high school. It was then that Jeremy knew he was gay, but Tad wasn't. He went through his frustrations alone and was saddened each time Tad brought a new girlfrien...

Barbarian Imprisoned

by sabb on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

This story is part of Barbarian Tales One, and follows the story Rescued by the Barbarian. * * * If the fine young nobleman was before me today, I confess I would still have the desire to take him long and hard. He was a very fine young nobleman, who had whatever it is a man needs to have to make me want him enough to be foolish about it. And each time I...

Aquata Cove Ch. 17

by Feare909 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Chapter 17: Mermaid Chorus Equipped with his trident, shoulder shells with the shark teeth cross-belts on his upper body, shell-kelp band around his head, Merrick and Adam walk to the small cliff over at the beach, under the night sky. His shell shard is vibrating and glowing on his chest as he walked. "Is there anyway I could be there without any of them...

Box Shaped Heart Ch. 19

by laurasfox on Feb 11, 2019
Gay Male

Chapter Nineteen - The Shape of Truth They stumbled inside, laughing and joking, and somehow ended on the carpet in the living room. The game had been incredible, they had stuffed their faces with hot dogs and they had spent their evening in a dive, drinking and singing with other fans. "Fuck, this was the most amazing night out in forever, Alex," Aron sa...