Gay Surprise Stories

7,723 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Bathhouse Summer's End Ch. 03

by glory_first on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Downstairs, there were enough towels around to make a cautious estimate concerning how long it would take before some stranger and I were playing with each other's cocks. Shortly was the simple answer, though the jacuzzi had to be factored into the calculation. Seeing at least 6 men in the bubbling jacuzzi, I showered thoroughly after my previous encounter...

Thomas and Niko Ch. 08

by kidboise on Jan 8, 2019
Gay Male

Thomas and Niko in the City of Trees - Chapter 8 — So word gets around and about twenty-five people show up. Owen's cousin works at Urban Brewing and supplied a keg, which is a pretty big windfall in case you didn't know. We all chipped in and Thomas and I went down the hill to Garden City to pick it up. Anyway, it's getting close to ten now, and everybody...

Finding Myself and My Best Friend

by turboscot on Aug 17, 2017
Gay Male

I've decided after talking to a friend that its time I put a few thoughts down in writing, and share them. After all, what harm can it do? I've found retelling this story has rekindled a lot of memories and feelings, that I thought I'd left in the past. This is a true story about how I found myself, and how my best friend and I found each other. *****...

Tight Squeeze Ch. 02

by sr71plt on Aug 22, 2017
Gay Male

After I was finished fucking Chris, I reached up and down and released his restraints. Then I stripped off the gloves and threw them to the side. But I just lay there, my dong eight and a half inches up Chris's ass and my arms and legs closely enclosing his, for a half hour or more. Chris lay quietly within my grasp, his breath becoming more and more regular...

Pete's Birthday Surprise

by alexcarr on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

"Are you in there, Badger?" barked Jeff knocking at the allotment shed door. "Hang on just a moment" was the gruff reply. "What you doing in there, sounds like you are out of breath," continued Jeff teasing, knowing very well what the old guy was up to with the young Pete. Or so he thought , but not quite as he discovered when Badger replied - he wasn't ac...

An Early Morning Surprise

by 46204_zipper on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I am a runner. As a 70 something male I work hard to stay in shape. I am also bisexual. I still enjoy the bottoms of men and women, and on occasion, let both fuck mine. What do these have to do with each other? Let me explain. I live in Indianapolis, Indiana. We have a fabulous running trail on an old railroad right of way called the Monon Trail. I am on th...

Straight Man Cums in Gay Massage

by Rosko Busby 2005 on Sep 1, 2017
Gay Male

Shane explodes in Special Gay Massage for Straights The five of us who ran the local gym were all gay and regular sex partners. We had shared many group sessions where we pretended to capture one of the group and subject him to fucking and torture. One of the fantasies we shared though was to do this for real and to force a good looking straight chap into j...

A Surprise in the Changing Room

by binut on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I'm a gas engineer by trade and spent this particular Friday afternoon servicing the boilers at my local leisure centre. The door to the small boiler room I was working in was almost opposite the men's changing room door, I saw a couple of middle aged guys go in to get changed. Both men reappeared in squash kit and headed for the courts, the second guy gav...

Living with an Exhibitionist Ch. 09

by jakeonthebox on Mar 26, 2019
Gay Male

I stood still, a little bit in shock, at what Terry had just said. He watched me, looking slightly amused at my reaction. "Why do you look so surprised?" "I dunno... that was kind of out of left field." "Dude, really? You don't think everything that's been happening between us hasn't been leading up to that? "Listen, I like your body, and I'm glad you le...

Who Could It Be?!

by timmyk on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

A knock on my door woke me. Stumbling in the darkness I managed to turn on the lamp on the night table. Rubbing my eyes I looked at the clock; 2:30 in the morning. I then looked down at my naked body. I always slept naked. I loved the feel of the smooth sheets on my freshly-cleaned body. I rummaged around for a pair of gym shorts and pulled them on as the do...