Gay Surprise Stories

7,723 results
Orientation
Length
Source
Infinite Scroll

Cleaning Day

by kudzu41999 on Aug 31, 2017
Gay Male

Gilbert called my parents and asked if I could come over to help him. He was an elderly retired gentlemen whom my parents had befriended at my church. Since I was desperately in need of spending money and Gilbert was so generous with my older brother, I consented. Spending time with elderly men was not something that appealed to me, but I convinced myself th...

House on Park Ch. 02

by sr71plt on Aug 17, 2017
Gay Male

Eric must have enjoyed the polishing job we'd done on the trunk of his Tempest, because when I'd finished shooting off into him, he said, "Well, Peter, if you'll get this beautiful body off mine and stop entertaining the neighbors, perhaps we should go in and shower." "I want to fuck again. I want you to fuck me," I said, without moving. "That's not out of...

First Time In Front of My Wife

by glmike523 on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

One of the best days I ever had with my wife, sexually that is, is when she watched me suck a cock for the first time. At the time we were married about 15 years and from the beginning she had always said to me she would like to see me with another guy. Little did she know that I actually craved to have sex with a man. Earlier in my life, before being marrie...

My Best Birthday Present

by showtime20042005 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

"This is going to be the best birthday present you've ever had," Billy said, as he drained the last few drops of his coffee. I had been lamenting for weeks about the approach of my 40th birthday and Billy had taken me out for a birthday lunch to cheer me up. During lunch he kept hinting at a surprise birthday present, a present that would definitely involve...

Daddy's Little Nurse Ch. 02

by ElioV on Aug 22, 2018
Gay Male

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of incest or incest content. ***** It's been a few weeks and I am finally getting better. No more casts and my ankle is only a little sore still. But never mind that. I am still thinking about my son. He jacked me off. HE JACKED ME OFF. And I haven't even thought to do something for him until now. After he grad...

Cum Slut Ch. 02

by whbonney on Aug 28, 2017
Gay Male

After my first week of sucking cock, I sat back and thought about what I had done, and decided that I actually enjoyed it immensely and loved the taste of warm cum directly from it's source. So, the next thing I knew I had to do was become good at it. About two week later, the third guy that I had sucked wrote to me and we decided to meet again. This time h...

Triple Magnum Nabilum

by sr71plt on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

I had to turn my eyes away from the penetrating stare of Finn Bergstrum, so I took my first good look at his assistant, Nabil. "Satyr" was the first thought that entered my mind, and I almost was able to imagine two little horns above his ears there. Sharp, swarthy features with that almost sneer of a smile that was close to the edge of presumption and cruel...

Suppository Depository

by kudzu41999 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

"Why are you constipated?" asked the old man. "Sorry," I said, "I don't like vegetables, fiber, oatmeal, salads, or anything green." I could not believe I was telling Gilbert my deepest darkest secrets. Still, Gilbert had always been there for me. Sure, he was so much older than me, but the old man listened to me and never criticized me. The old man shrug...

Drowsy Driving

by ophanim on Oct 22, 2019
Gay Male

I noticed that David was a bit drowsing off on the wheel. It was to be expected as we had driven for about twelve hours and we still had three to go, in the pitch dark night. I was grateful of him to have taken me outstate for our vacation week, but the long car trip was really not that fun during a heatwave. The vacation in themselves had been fun, we trie...

Meeting Bruce

by sunset_lover on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

The other weekend I was relaxing, surfing, and found an ad online that looked interesting. I sent him an email, and introduced myself. He wrote me back, and we emailed back and forth a few times before we called each other. We talked for a bit before we decided to meet and I headed over there. I walked into his house and shook his hand. He stood about 6'2"...