Gay Ugly Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Category
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com
Create your own smut fantasy with AI

Me and the Neighbor's Kid

by uglyTrouble on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

Deals, I hate them. More or less, just because if I don't keep my word than I blew up a bridge that might be important later. The one deal I hate the most is my most current one, however, before I tell you the deal and the story surrounding it, you need to understand me as well as a few... important details. My name is Kyle. I live in Georgia. I'm 28 years...

Finally Facialed

by StarWars00 on Mar 13, 2018
Gay Male

He's pulling up. Hoping he's not ugly and has some class. This isn't a hot date or anything but meeting him for the first time I can't help but to wonder if we'll like this. I hope so. I'm horny. And if his cock is nice as he advertised then we'll be a-ok. Make him pull up to a house around the corner. I'm sure he's curious more than I am as he waits for...

Curious

by Reverse_Cowboy on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

My name is Jack Miller and I’m 20 years old. It’s been about a year since I’ve had a girlfriend or gotten any sex for that matter. I’m far from ugly, but I’m not what most girls would consider to be a hunk or a stud either. I’m 5’9” tall, weigh about 140 pounds and I have brown eyes and light brown hair I keep in a crew cut. I have an 8-inch long dick that’s...

Wishful Thinking Ch. 03

by taylorreed on Sep 14, 2017
Gay Male

Hi again everyone. If you are looking to "get off" then this is not the story for you. This is an ongoing challenge for me to finish this and I have been putting it off but no longer...It gets ugly and dark and some of it I find hard to believe ever happened because in spite of it all...Here I am. Still standing. Most of all I just pray that if you read this...

Gay Diploma Pt. 02: Ivan the Wonder

by newpaulman on Sep 16, 2017
Gay Male

And so to the afternoon session. My arse still tinglingly aware of Dili's attention, I make my way to bedroom 2 and the "ugly Latvian". Ivan at least knows the English for "Come in", or something like it. He is sitting in a chair, wearing a white bathrobe and when I enter he stands up and lets it fall from his body. He has a pug-like face, with a large, fla...

Low Inhibitions

by impact499 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

When I'm horny even as much as a heterosexual male as I am the idea of having another man take me raises its ugly head. I remember it started so innocently. I don't know how old I was but I know even now that it started with pornography. I loved women and I loved looking at women. It didn't matter if they were white, black, Asian or Latin as long as they ha...

Move In Day

by bboy13 on Aug 18, 2017
Gay Male

It was move in day at the college. I was expecting my roommate to be unattractive, fat and ugly. I was dreading the thought that he was not who I was expecting him to be. I got a text message. "Text me when you get here, and I will help you bring your things up to the room." I guess the elevator was not working like what it should have, and running slower t...

A Shameless, Nameless Fuck

by newpaulman on Jul 16, 2019
Gay Male

When I logged on to the sex dating site, as I did every day, browsing the women, I was surprised to see an ugly male face appear. Surely the site had rules about this and made sure people didn't slip themselves into the wrong category. I was looking for a woman - a nice, mature, slightly bulky, woman-next-door type. But what I was looking at was a cropped h...

Jason's First Gangbang

by gwariola on Dec 31, 2019
Gay Male

Editor's note: this submission contains scenes of non-consensual or reluctant sexual situations. My name's Jason. I was always a decent looking guy. Not movie star levels of hot, but far from ugly. I'm right at six feet tall and about 165 pounds. Brown hair, blue eyes. Not in bad shape, but don't have too much muscle definition. I've always wanted six pack...

Trucker's Weekend of Fun - Night 01

by SubForSir on Oct 6, 2020
Gay Male

He didn't even let me close the door. As soon as I'd entered the room, he was there pushing me against ugly wallpaper. A large, warm hand grabbed my chin, tilting my face upwards as its partner cupped the nape of my neck. A line of fire burned down my spine as his right hand slid until he clutched my ass and lifted me. I wasn't even given a second to recover...