Lesbian Butt Plug Stories

1,000 results
Orientation
Length
Category
Source
Infinite Scroll
SmutMD: The World's Biggest Erotic Literature Search Engine.
© 2026 SmutMD.com
Create your own smut fantasy with AI

Consequences

by cornixregina on Sep 16, 2017
Lesbian Sex

We stripped and you put a butt plug up my arse then forced me down into a seat and cuffed my hands behind my back and tied my ankles to the front legs of the chair then took another chair for yourself and sat down facing me took out your dildo opened your legs and started fucking yourself in front of me. I sit there watching you satisfying yourself unable to...

Abigail Ch. 01

by margaret_jenkins on Sep 16, 2017
Lesbian Sex

A few days after my "plugging" Lauren asked me if she could invite her long-time school-friend, Abigail to visit for the coming week. Abigail was a charming girl and Lauren's best friend t school. She had often spent the evening while they did their homework together, and occasionally slept over. She was somewhat shy, a quiet bookish girl who wore glasses an...

Briefs No. 01: An Unexpected Plug

by PatriciaFCartier on Jul 16, 2019
Lesbian Sex

Editor's note: this story contains scenes of incest or incest content. (Hello. I've been away for a while, mostly working on short forms as tricias-captions on Tumblr. But they decided what they decided and I guess I'm back. Longer form requires less attention-deficit disorder. :-) So, I'm not sure what will come of it. Anyway, this is medium-length fiction...

Adventures with Emma Ch. 01

by butterflibaby on Sep 15, 2017
Lesbian Sex

I was so nervous. I was almost to the restaurant where Emma and I were supposed to meet for the first time. I squirmed in my seat, sharply reminded that Andrew had ordered me to wear my butt plug for the meeting. I grumbled to myself, I knew I would be squirming and blushing so bad. Andrew also ordered that I tell her if she asked why I was behaving so oddly...

Beside the Pool

by Hornyoldwoman947 on Jul 16, 2019
Lesbian Sex

The Beginning of a new Relationship. This is more of a love story. Very light M/s. We'll see where this goes. I've purchased a set of butt plugs just for you. I know you have reservations about using them, but I want you to be able to enjoy being fucked in the ass. The training these butt plugs accomplish is well worth the effort. I've selected the smalle...

Miranda and Geraldine Ch. 05

by StoryTeller07 on Sep 26, 2017
Lesbian Sex

Chapter 05 The wealthy woman submits completely Geraldine awoke remembering last nights feeling of contentment, with her lowly position of pet-girl, and cringed from the disgrace of it. That young girl had stuck a butt plug up her ass, attached a tail to it, and she had thanked her for it. How low could she get! The memory of being fucked by the girl left...

The Adventures of Katie and Sarah Ch. 05

by sugarisnice on Sep 12, 2017
Lesbian Sex

Several months had passed since Katie and Sarah were Pony properties of Jackie and Tina, their sorority sisters who sold them to Katie's former high school principal and her lover. Joan, the school's award winning principal, was keeping Katie and Sarah hidden away in her mansion, only bringing them out to savagely rape them at her whim. It got to the point...

Student Lesbian BDSM Ch. 05

by NPC01 on Sep 25, 2017
Lesbian Sex

I sat in the passenger seat of the BMW. Every minute we drove I got more and more nervous. Erica's driving didn't do much to subdue my growing agitation. For the whole journey she drove at the highest speed the limit would allow. I sat desperately clutching the fabric of my seat every time a bend in the road approached. Until now I hadn't thought it possib...

Unlocking Tally Ch. 05

by NerdyNymph on Sep 16, 2017
Lesbian Sex

"Hey, Tally, you want anything from the cafe?" Claire asked. "No thanks, I'm full." As I said it, I could hear Rei snickering beside me. Panic swept over me, and I shot her a look that was intended to silence. Instead, incredulity was all she offered in return. True, it was a quiet, stifled laugh, and, true, it's not like anyone there had the slightest ide...

Lesbian Vampire Whores Ch. 04

by OLB on Sep 11, 2017
Lesbian Sex

Cynthia awakened wanting sex. Her breasts ached for attention, and her pussy literally throbbed with need. She could feel the plug nestled in her ass and clenched her muscles against it. A delicious sensation ran up her belly and back down to her clit. "Our baby is awake," Monica purred and moved the sheets aside so she could look at this sweet and oh so te...